Climate Change and Mandatory Carbon
Reporting: Impacts on Business Processes and Corporate Performance in India
Title Page
Original Research Theme: Climate Change and Mandatory
Carbon Reporting: Impacts on Business Process and Performance
Original journal article details:
·
Title: Climate Change and
Mandatory Carbon Reporting: Impacts on Business Process and Performance
·
Authors: Samuel Tang and David
Demeritt
·
Journal: Business Strategy
and the Environment
·
Volume: 27, Issue 4
·
Pages: 437–455 (2018)
DOI: 10.1002/bse.1985
India-Focused Research Title: Climate Change and Mandatory Carbon Reporting: Impacts on Business Processes and Corporate Performance in India
Research Paper Type: Secondary-data-based empirical and
analytical case-cum-research study
Author: Dr. Mamta Vyas
Affiliation: Independent Researcher – Management and
Economics
Research Focus: SEBI's Business Responsibility and
Sustainability Reporting (BRSR), corporate environmental disclosure,
organizational behaviour, energy efficiency, emission reduction, and financial
performance.
Research Period: FY 2022–23 to FY 2024–25, with regulatory
developments considered through 2026.
Abstract
Climate change has emerged as a significant economic, managerial,
regulatory, and strategic challenge for Indian businesses. Corporate greenhouse
gas (GHG) emissions are increasingly subject to scrutiny from investors,
regulators, consumers, employees, and international supply-chain partners. In
India, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) introduced the
Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) framework in 2021,
making sustainability disclosure mandatory for the top 1,000 listed companies
from FY 2022–23. This research examines the extent to which mandatory carbon
reporting influences business processes, corporate governance, operational
efficiency, financial performance, and environmental outcomes in India.
The study employs a secondary-data-based research methodology combining
regulatory analysis, documentary examination, sectoral comparisons, and
published empirical studies. It draws upon SEBI's BRSR framework, the Indian
Institute for Human Settlements' analysis of 150 listed companies, the CFA
Institute's research on BRSR disclosures, and the Council on Energy,
Environment and Water's analysis of Indian corporate environmental reporting.
The paper examines three major corporate motivations for carbon reporting:
financial efficiency, reputational management, and regulatory compliance.
The findings indicate that mandatory reporting has strengthened
sustainability-related information systems, increased organizational attention
to environmental performance, and improved the visibility of corporate
emissions. Nevertheless, disclosure does not automatically translate into
absolute emission reductions. Reporting quality, assurance, sectoral
characteristics, organizational capabilities, and the economic incentives
associated with energy consumption significantly influence the effectiveness of
the reporting framework. The study concludes that India requires a transition
from disclosure-oriented sustainability governance towards performance-oriented
carbon accountability, supported by verified data, sector-specific targets,
operational improvements, and stronger regulatory integration.
Keywords: Climate Change, Mandatory Carbon Reporting, BRSR,
Corporate Sustainability, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Corporate Performance
1. Introduction
1.1 Background of the Study
Climate change is increasingly influencing the business environment through
rising temperatures, extreme weather events, resource scarcity, energy-price
volatility, regulatory changes, and growing stakeholder expectations regarding
environmental responsibility.
Businesses contribute to climate change through activities such as:
·
Fossil-fuel combustion in manufacturing and
transportation.
·
Electricity consumption in offices, factories,
and commercial buildings.
·
Industrial production processes in cement,
steel, chemicals, and fertilisers.
·
Supply-chain operations and logistics.
·
Product use and disposal.
·
Land-use changes and resource extraction.
Corporate carbon emissions have traditionally been considered an
environmental issue. However, they are now increasingly recognized as a management
and economic issue because emission-intensive operations may create additional
costs, regulatory exposure, investment risks, and reputational challenges.
In India, the importance of corporate environmental accountability has
increased due to the country's industrial expansion, infrastructure
development, energy demand, and international climate commitments.
The Indian corporate sector faces a dual challenge:
1. Achieving
economic growth, profitability, employment generation, and industrial
competitiveness.
2. Reducing
environmental impacts and improving resource efficiency.
Mandatory carbon reporting has emerged as a mechanism through which
regulators attempt to reconcile these two objectives.
1.2 Evolution of Mandatory
Sustainability Reporting in India
India has developed a distinctive regulatory structure for corporate
responsibility.
The evolution of India's corporate sustainability reporting can be
understood through the following stages.
Table 1. Evolution of Corporate Sustainability Reporting in India
|
Period |
Regulatory development |
Business implication |
|
2009 |
National Voluntary Guidelines on CSR |
Initial voluntary sustainability practices |
|
2012 |
SEBI introduces Business Responsibility Reporting (BRR) for the top 100
listed entities |
Formal ESG disclosure begins |
|
2013 |
Companies Act, Section 135 |
Statutory CSR expenditure requirement for qualifying companies |
|
2015 onwards |
BRR expanded to larger listed-company population |
Wider sustainability accountability |
|
May 2021 |
SEBI introduces BRSR |
Standardized ESG reporting architecture |
|
FY 2022–23 |
BRSR becomes mandatory for top 1,000 listed companies by market
capitalization |
Mandatory sustainability reporting |
|
July 2023 |
BRSR Core framework introduced |
Greater emphasis on measurable indicators and assurance |
|
March 2025 |
SEBI modifies value-chain disclosure provisions |
Value-chain ESG disclosures become voluntary from FY 2025–26 under the
revised provisions |
SEBI's BRSR framework requires companies to report information relating to
environmental, social, and governance performance. Environmental disclosures
include energy consumption, water use, greenhouse gas emissions, emission
intensity, and environmental targets.
Securities and Exchange Board of India+2
The Indian system therefore represents more than a voluntary sustainability initiative.
It has created a formal reporting responsibility for large listed companies.
1.3 Statement of the Research
Problem
The central problem is that corporate carbon disclosure and corporate
environmental performance are not necessarily identical.
A company may disclose:
·
Its total greenhouse gas emissions.
·
Energy consumption.
·
Carbon intensity.
·
Environmental targets.
·
Renewable energy investments.
·
Sustainability initiatives.
However, the existence of these disclosures does not establish that the
company has achieved a meaningful reduction in its absolute emissions.
A business may report improved carbon intensity while its total emissions
continue to increase because of higher production, expanded operations, or
business growth.
For example, a cement company may reduce its carbon emissions per tonne of
cement produced but increase its total annual emissions because its production
capacity expands.
Similarly, an IT company may publish a comprehensive sustainability report
but have limited influence over emissions arising from rented office buildings,
electricity suppliers, employee commuting, or its supply chain.
The research problem can therefore be stated as follows:
To what extent does mandatory carbon reporting under India's BRSR
framework influence corporate business processes, organizational behaviour,
financial performance, and actual environmental outcomes, rather than merely
improving the quantity of sustainability disclosures?
1.4 Research Objectives
The study aims to:
1. Examine
the development and implementation of mandatory carbon reporting in India.
2. Identify
the financial, reputational, and regulatory motivations behind corporate carbon
disclosure.
3. Analyse
the impact of carbon reporting on internal business processes and
organizational coordination.
4. Examine
the relationship between carbon reporting, energy efficiency, and corporate
financial performance.
5. Evaluate
the gap between sustainability disclosure and actual emission reduction.
6. Compare
carbon-reporting behaviour across energy-intensive and non-energy-intensive
sectors.
7. Identify
the limitations of India's BRSR framework.
8. Recommend
policy and managerial measures for strengthening carbon accountability.
1.5 Research Questions
The research addresses the following questions:
·
RQ1: What motivates Indian companies to disclose
greenhouse gas emissions?
·
RQ2: How does mandatory carbon reporting affect
internal business processes?
·
RQ3: Does carbon reporting contribute to
improved financial and operational performance?
·
RQ4: Does mandatory reporting result in actual
reductions in corporate emissions?
·
RQ5: How do sectoral differences influence the
effectiveness of BRSR?
·
RQ6: What improvements are required to transform
carbon disclosure into measurable environmental performance?
1.6 Research Hypotheses
The following hypotheses are proposed for future statistical testing using
firm-level panel data.
|
Hypothesis |
Statement |
|
H1 |
Mandatory carbon reporting is positively associated with the development
of corporate environmental data systems. |
|
H2 |
Carbon reporting is positively associated with energy-efficiency
initiatives in energy-intensive industries. |
|
H3 |
The relationship between carbon reporting and financial performance is
stronger in energy-intensive industries than in service industries. |
|
H4 |
Higher-quality carbon disclosure is positively associated with
environmental performance. |
|
H5 |
External assurance of carbon disclosures is positively associated with the
reliability of reported environmental information. |
|
H6 |
Mandatory carbon reporting alone is insufficient to ensure absolute
reductions in corporate GHG emissions. |
These hypotheses are research propositions. The present secondary-data study
does not claim to have statistically validated all six hypotheses.
2. Literature Review
2.1 Corporate Social Responsibility
and Environmental Disclosure
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) refers to the responsibility of
business organizations towards society, the environment, employees, consumers,
and other stakeholders.
Environmental disclosure has become an important component of CSR because
stakeholders increasingly demand information about the ecological consequences
of corporate activities.
Traditional financial reporting primarily communicates profitability,
assets, liabilities, and cash flows. Sustainability reporting expands the scope
of corporate accountability by providing information about non-financial
performance.
However, researchers have raised questions about whether sustainability
reporting genuinely changes organizational behaviour or merely serves as an
instrument of corporate image management.
Bansal and Roth [1] explain that organizational responses to environmental
concerns are influenced by ecological, economic, and legitimacy-related
motivations.
In the Indian context, BRSR creates a standardized reporting structure. Yet
the central challenge remains whether companies integrate environmental
information into managerial decisions.
2.2 Institutional Theory and
Mandatory Carbon Reporting
Institutional theory suggests that organizations respond to external institutional
pressures.
These pressures may take three forms:
Coercive pressure: Companies comply with mandatory
regulatory requirements.
Normative pressure: Companies respond to expectations from
professional bodies, investors, auditors, and sustainability experts.
Mimetic pressure: Companies imitate competitors and
industry leaders when environmental reporting becomes a recognized corporate
practice.
Under India's BRSR framework, coercive pressure is particularly important
because listed companies are required to submit prescribed sustainability
disclosures.
However, compliance does not necessarily indicate substantive environmental
transformation.
A company may establish an ESG department and prepare an annual
sustainability report primarily to satisfy regulatory requirements, while its
operational processes remain unchanged.
This distinction between formal compliance and substantive performance is
fundamental to the present research.
2.3 Legitimacy Theory and
Greenwashing
Legitimacy theory argues that companies seek to maintain social acceptance
by aligning their organizational behaviour with societal expectations.
Carbon reporting can strengthen legitimacy by communicating that the company
is environmentally responsible.
However, legitimacy-oriented disclosure may also become selective.
Companies may emphasize:
·
Renewable energy installations.
·
Tree plantation initiatives.
·
Carbon-neutrality commitments.
·
Energy-saving projects.
·
Sustainability awards.
At the same time, they may provide insufficient attention to:
·
Rising absolute emissions.
·
Emissions from supply chains.
·
Industrial pollution.
·
Environmental violations.
·
Failure to achieve previously announced targets.
Such practices may create a disclosure-performance gap commonly associated
with greenwashing.
In India, the possibility of BRSR-washing is relevant where sustainability
reports contain extensive qualitative information but lack comparable,
independently verified environmental performance data.
2.4 Financial Efficiency and
Environmental Management
Environmental reporting may improve financial performance when it helps
companies identify operational inefficiencies.
Energy consumption is a direct cost for many industries. Consequently,
monitoring emissions may help organizations identify opportunities for:
·
Reducing electricity consumption.
·
Improving machinery efficiency.
·
Optimizing transportation routes.
·
Reducing fuel consumption.
·
Minimizing waste.
·
Improving production processes.
Porter and van der Linde [2] argue that environmental improvements may
stimulate innovation and efficiency, although such benefits are not automatic.
The financial relationship between carbon reporting and corporate
performance depends upon the industry.
For a steel manufacturer, energy and fuel costs can be significant. For a
financial services company, electricity-related expenses may constitute a
comparatively small proportion of total operating costs.
Thus, identical reporting obligations may produce different economic
outcomes across sectors.
2.5 Indian Research on BRSR
Disclosure
The Indian Institute for Human Settlements published a study in November
2024 examining sustainability disclosures of 150 companies listed on the Bombay
Stock Exchange. The study identified trends and gaps in India's BRSR
implementation.
IIHS+1
The CFA Institute and CFA Society India also examined BRSR disclosures,
reporting improvements in the availability of environmental data alongside
continuing inconsistencies in reporting quality.
CFA Institute Research and Policy Center+1
These studies indicate that India's sustainability reporting system has
developed considerably. Nevertheless, the availability of information does not
necessarily establish that the information is sufficiently comparable or that
it has resulted in a causal improvement in environmental performance.
2.6 Research Gap
The literature reveals four important gaps.
|
Research gap |
Explanation |
|
Disclosure-performance gap |
Reporting may increase without absolute emission reductions. |
|
Sectoral gap |
Different industries have unequal economic incentives to reduce emissions. |
|
Organizational gap |
The influence of reporting on finance, procurement, operations, and
management remains uneven. |
|
Assurance gap |
The credibility and comparability of environmental information require
stronger verification. |
The present study addresses these gaps through an India-focused analysis of
mandatory carbon reporting and its relationship with business processes and
corporate performance.
3. Research Methodology
3.1 Research Design
The study adopts a descriptive, analytical, and interpretive research
design.
The research combines:
·
Documentary analysis of SEBI regulations and
BRSR requirements.
·
Secondary-data analysis of published empirical
research.
·
Sectoral comparison of corporate environmental
reporting.
·
Conceptual analysis of business-process impacts.
·
Critical evaluation of the relationship between
disclosure and performance.
The methodology is designed to assess the institutional and managerial
implications of mandatory carbon reporting in India.
3.2 Nature of Data
The study uses secondary data collected from the following sources.
Table 2. Sources of Secondary Data
|
Source |
Data utilized |
|
SEBI |
BRSR regulations, BRSR Core, reporting and assurance requirements |
|
IIHS |
Analysis of disclosures from 150 Indian companies |
|
CFA Institute |
BRSR reporting trends and environmental performance indicators |
|
CEEW |
Analysis of BRSR environmental disclosure and data quality |
|
Ministry of Power |
Energy efficiency and industrial policy |
|
Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) |
PAT and carbon market mechanisms |
|
Company annual reports |
Corporate sustainability strategies and emission disclosures |
|
Academic journals |
CSR, institutional theory, legitimacy theory, and carbon reporting |
The study does not claim to have conducted original interviews or
independently collected a complete 1,000-company dataset. Published results are
distinguished from the researcher's analytical interpretation.
3.3 Study Population
The principal population is Indian listed companies subject to mandatory
BRSR disclosure.
The primary regulatory population comprises the top 1,000 listed companies
by market capitalization.
For comparative analysis, the study considers five major industrial
categories:
1. Energy
and power.
2. Cement,
steel, and manufacturing.
3. Information
technology and financial services.
4. Transportation
and logistics.
5. Consumer
goods and retail.
3.4 Analytical Framework
The research adopts the following conceptual model.
The framework suggests that mandatory reporting influences environmental
performance through multiple intermediate mechanisms.
The effectiveness of reporting depends on whether companies convert
information into operational decisions.
3.5 Data Analysis Techniques
The study employs:
·
Descriptive statistical analysis of published
disclosure indicators.
·
Percentage-based comparison.
·
Sectoral analysis.
·
Comparative trend analysis.
·
Qualitative interpretation of regulatory and
organizational changes.
·
Critical analysis of disclosure-performance
relationships.
The analysis is not presented as a causal econometric test. A future panel-data
study could use regression, difference-in-differences, or other suitable
methods to test the proposed hypotheses.
3.6 Ethical Considerations
The study uses publicly available regulatory and research information. No
confidential corporate information or private interview data is used.
All empirical statistics are attributed to their original sources.
Interpretive claims are identified as analytical conclusions rather than direct
observations.
4. Mandatory Carbon Reporting in
India: Regulatory and Institutional Framework
4.1 SEBI's Business Responsibility
and Sustainability Report
SEBI introduced BRSR in May 2021, replacing the earlier Business
Responsibility Report.
The framework became mandatory for the top 1,000 listed companies from FY
2022–23. It is structured around nine principles of the National Guidelines on
Responsible Business Conduct.
Principle 6 specifically addresses environmental responsibility.
Companies are expected to disclose information relating to:
·
Energy consumption.
·
Energy intensity.
·
Water consumption and discharge.
·
Air emissions.
·
Scope 1 greenhouse gas emissions.
·
Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions.
·
Emission intensity.
·
Environmental initiatives and targets.
SEBI's BRSR framework is intended to improve standardization and
comparability of environmental, social, and governance information.
Securities and Exchange Board of India+1
4.2 Scope of Corporate Carbon
Emissions
The Greenhouse Gas Protocol classifies corporate emissions into three
scopes.
Table 3. Classification of Corporate Greenhouse Gas Emissions
|
Scope |
Description |
Indian business example |
|
Scope 1 |
Direct emissions from sources owned or controlled by the company |
Diesel consumed by a cement plant |
|
Scope 2 |
Indirect emissions from purchased electricity, heat, or steam |
Electricity consumed by an IT company |
|
Scope 3 |
Other indirect emissions across the value chain |
Supplier emissions, logistics, employee travel, product use |
Scope 1 and Scope 2 are central to mandatory BRSR reporting. Scope 3
reporting is an important leadership indicator and is increasingly relevant for
supply-chain accountability.
However, Scope 3 emissions can be difficult to measure because they require
data from suppliers, distributors, customers, and other external parties.
4.3 BRSR Core and Assurance
SEBI introduced BRSR Core in July 2023, establishing a subset of ESG
indicators intended for assurance.
The original glide path was:
Table 4. Original BRSR Core Assurance Glide Path
|
Financial year |
Companies by market
capitalization |
|
FY 2023–24 |
Top 150 |
|
FY 2024–25 |
Top 250 |
|
FY 2025–26 |
Top 500 |
|
FY 2026–27 |
Top 1,000 |
The assurance requirement aims to improve the reliability of corporate ESG
information.
Securities and Exchange Board of India+1
Regulatory qualification: SEBI issued subsequent amendments and
clarifications. The original glide path above should not be interpreted as an
unqualified statement of the current legal position. For current compliance,
companies must follow the latest SEBI circulars and master circulars.
4.4 India's Carbon Market
Architecture
India's corporate carbon-reporting framework operates alongside other energy
and environmental policies.
These include:
·
Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT) scheme.
·
Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS).
·
Energy Conservation Act and its 2022 amendment.
·
Environmental clearance and pollution-control
requirements.
·
Renewable energy policies.
·
National climate commitments.
The PAT scheme promotes energy efficiency among designated energy-intensive
industries.
The Carbon Credit Trading Scheme creates a framework for carbon-credit
trading under India's developing carbon market architecture.
The coexistence of these instruments is important because BRSR primarily
requires disclosure, whereas PAT and carbon market mechanisms may create more
direct economic incentives for environmental improvement.
5. Rationales for Mandatory Carbon
Reporting
The research identifies three primary motivations for Indian corporate
carbon reporting:
1. Financial
rationales.
2. Reputational
rationales.
3. Regulatory
rationales.
5.1 Financial Rationales
5.1.1 Energy Efficiency and Cost
Reduction
For energy-intensive industries, carbon reporting is closely connected to
cost management.
Energy consumption may constitute a substantial component of production
costs in sectors such as cement, steel, aluminium, fertilisers, and power
generation.
Carbon reporting can assist management in identifying:
·
Excessive fuel consumption.
·
Inefficient production equipment.
·
Electricity wastage.
·
Process-related emission sources.
·
Opportunities for renewable energy adoption.
The financial rationale is therefore stronger where emission reduction and
cost reduction occur simultaneously.
5.1.2 Corporate Example: Indian
Cement Industry
Cement production is associated with emissions from fuel combustion and the
chemical process of clinker production.
A cement company may use BRSR data to identify:
·
High energy consumption per tonne of cement.
·
Excessive dependence on coal and petcoke.
·
Opportunities for waste-heat recovery.
·
Alternative fuel utilization.
·
Renewable electricity procurement.
For example, consider a hypothetical company producing 10 million tonnes of
cement annually.
If the company reduces energy costs by ₹50 per tonne through efficiency
improvements, the annual cost saving would be:
\[ 10,000,000 \times ₹50 = ₹500,000,000 \]
Illustrative annual savings: ₹50 crore
This is a hypothetical calculation, not an actual corporate performance
result.
The example demonstrates how carbon measurement may become a tool of cost
optimization.
5.1.3 Corporate Example: Tata Steel
Steel manufacturing involves substantial energy consumption and process
emissions.
Carbon reporting can help a steel company evaluate:
·
Blast-furnace efficiency.
·
Fuel consumption.
·
Renewable electricity.
·
Process innovation.
·
Scrap utilization.
·
Alternative production technologies.
The financial motivation is especially relevant where carbon-related costs,
energy expenditure, or customer requirements influence competitiveness.
However, reporting itself does not guarantee that technological changes will
be economically viable.
5.1.4 Financial Rationale in IT and
Financial Services
The financial rationale differs in service industries.
IT companies and financial institutions may have lower direct emissions than
heavy manufacturing firms, but their emissions can arise from:
·
Data centres.
·
Purchased electricity.
·
Commercial buildings.
·
Employee commuting.
·
Business travel.
·
Outsourced services.
For these companies, carbon reporting may be less important as a direct
cost-reduction mechanism and more important as a means of satisfying investors
and international customers.
5.1.5 Sectoral Comparison
Table 5. Financial Incentives for Carbon Reporting in Indian Industries
|
Industry |
Energy intensity |
Financial incentive |
Likely reporting motivation |
|
Cement |
Very high |
High |
Cost reduction and carbon efficiency |
|
Steel |
Very high |
High |
Energy management and transition investment |
|
Aluminium |
Very high |
High |
Electricity efficiency and regulatory exposure |
|
Power generation |
Very high |
High |
Emissions management and compliance |
|
IT services |
Low to moderate direct intensity |
Moderate |
Client, investor, and reputation requirements |
|
Banking |
Low direct operational intensity |
Low direct incentive |
ESG risk management and financed-emissions concerns |
|
Retail |
Moderate |
Moderate |
Logistics and electricity optimization |
|
Pharmaceuticals |
Moderate |
Moderate |
Process efficiency and supply-chain reporting |
The table represents a conceptual sectoral classification, not a measured
financial ranking.
5.2 Reputational Rationales
5.2.1 Investor Pressure
Investors increasingly consider environmental risks when evaluating
corporate strategy and long-term financial sustainability.
Carbon reporting may influence:
·
Investment screening.
·
ESG ratings.
·
Corporate valuation.
·
Risk assessment.
·
Institutional investor engagement.
·
Access to international capital.
A company with reliable environmental data may be better positioned to
communicate its climate risks and transition plans.
However, the existence of an ESG report does not necessarily mean that the
company has achieved superior environmental performance.
5.2.2 Supply-Chain Reputation
Indian firms operating in international supply chains may face
climate-related data requirements from overseas customers.
This is especially relevant to:
·
IT services.
·
Automobile components.
·
Pharmaceuticals.
·
Textiles.
·
Electronics manufacturing.
·
Engineering exports.
A supplier may be asked to disclose emissions because its international
buyer must report value-chain emissions.
Thus, carbon reporting can become a market-access requirement rather than
simply a regulatory obligation.
5.2.3 Corporate Image and
Greenwashing
Corporate sustainability reporting can improve reputation, but it may also
be used for selective image management.
For example, a company may prominently display its renewable-energy
investments while giving limited attention to the increase in its total
emissions.
This creates a distinction between:
·
Environmental communication.
·
Environmental performance.
The distinction is particularly important in evaluating Indian corporate
sustainability reports.
5.3 Regulatory Rationales
The regulatory rationale is central to BRSR.
Companies disclose environmental information because reporting is mandated
by SEBI.
Regulatory compliance may involve:
·
Establishing internal reporting procedures.
·
Appointing sustainability personnel.
·
Maintaining emission records.
·
Coordinating with finance and operations.
·
Preparing annual sustainability reports.
·
Seeking assurance where applicable.
The regulatory rationale can be summarized as follows:
Table 6. Regulatory Drivers and Corporate Responses
|
Regulatory driver |
Corporate response |
|
Mandatory BRSR filing |
Preparation of sustainability disclosures |
|
BRSR Core indicators |
Improved data control and measurement |
|
Assurance requirements |
Verification of selected ESG indicators |
|
PAT scheme |
Energy-efficiency monitoring |
|
Carbon market development |
Evaluation of carbon-credit opportunities |
|
Environmental regulations |
Integration of compliance and environmental management |
The regulatory framework can stimulate internal organizational change.
Nevertheless, the extent of change depends on whether companies view reporting
as a managerial tool or merely as a compliance exercise.
6. Impacts of Mandatory Carbon
Reporting on Business Processes and Internal Organization
The most important organizational impact of mandatory carbon reporting is
the potential transformation of environmental information from an external
reporting requirement into an internal management resource.
6.1 Internal Coordination and
Departmental Integration
Carbon reporting requires information from multiple departments.
The information required for BRSR may originate from:
·
Production and operations.
·
Finance and accounting.
·
Procurement.
·
Human resources.
·
Facilities management.
·
Logistics.
·
Sustainability and ESG departments.
·
Corporate strategy.
For example, a manufacturing company may require its production department
to report fuel consumption, finance to provide revenue data, procurement to
disclose supplier information, and sustainability personnel to consolidate
emission figures.
This creates opportunities for improved interdepartmental coordination.
Table 7. Departmental Impacts of
Carbon Reporting
|
Department |
Impact of carbon reporting |
|
Finance |
Integration of ESG information with financial reporting |
|
Operations |
Monitoring of fuel and energy efficiency |
|
Procurement |
Supplier sustainability assessment |
|
HR |
Employee commuting and environmental awareness |
|
Marketing |
Sustainability communication and reputation management |
|
Strategy |
Climate-related risk and investment planning |
|
Internal audit |
Verification of environmental data |
|
Sustainability |
Consolidation and interpretation of GHG information |
The process can improve organizational transparency, but it may also create
additional administrative work.
6.2 Development of Environmental
Information Systems
Companies may establish databases for recording:
·
Electricity consumption.
·
Diesel and natural gas consumption.
·
Production volumes.
·
Emission factors.
·
Waste generation.
·
Water consumption.
·
Renewable energy utilization.
The development of these systems may improve managerial decision-making.
However, smaller companies within the value chain may face difficulties due
to limited technological infrastructure, inadequate environmental expertise,
and higher reporting costs.
6.3 Emergence of Sustainability
Professionals
Mandatory reporting increases demand for professionals with expertise in:
·
Environmental accounting.
·
ESG reporting.
·
Carbon measurement.
·
Sustainability assurance.
·
Climate-risk management.
·
Energy management.
This creates a new area of professional specialization within Indian
corporate management.
At the same time, there is a risk that organizations focus primarily on
preparing sustainability reports rather than implementing operational changes.
6.4 Changes in Performance
Measurement
Carbon reporting can expand corporate performance measurement beyond
conventional financial indicators.
Table 8. Traditional and Sustainability-Oriented Performance Measurement
|
Traditional performance
indicators |
Sustainability-oriented
indicators |
|
Revenue |
Revenue per unit of carbon emissions |
|
Operating profit |
Energy cost per unit of output |
|
Return on investment |
Emission reduction investment |
|
Production volume |
Carbon intensity of production |
|
Cost of goods sold |
Renewable energy share |
|
Financial productivity |
Resource efficiency |
|
Market share |
Environmental performance |
The integration of financial and environmental performance measurement can
help companies understand whether sustainability initiatives improve economic
efficiency.
6.5 Carbon Reporting and Corporate
Decision-Making
Carbon information may influence managerial decisions in several areas.
Production Decisions
Managers may reconsider production processes with high emission intensity.
Investment Decisions
Companies may allocate capital to renewable energy, energy-efficient
equipment, and cleaner technologies.
Procurement Decisions
Organizations may select suppliers with lower environmental footprints.
Logistics Decisions
Companies may optimize transportation routes and improve vehicle
utilization.
Product Development
Businesses may design products that consume fewer resources during
manufacturing and use.
Corporate Strategy
Environmental performance may become an integral component of strategic
planning.
These changes are potential organizational effects. Their actual extent must
be examined through company-specific data.
7. Impacts of Mandatory Carbon
Reporting on Corporate Environmental and Financial Performance
7.1 Disclosure Versus Performance
A fundamental issue is the difference between reporting emissions and
reducing emissions.
A company can improve the quality of its sustainability reporting without
achieving a reduction in its emissions.
For example:
·
It may measure emissions more accurately.
·
It may disclose more environmental indicators.
·
It may appoint ESG professionals.
·
It may introduce emission-reduction targets.
Yet its absolute emissions may increase if production expands.
Consequently, carbon reporting must be assessed using both disclosure
indicators and environmental performance indicators.
7.2 Absolute Emissions and Emission
Intensity
Two major measures are used to evaluate corporate carbon performance.
Absolute emissions
Absolute emissions represent the total greenhouse gas emissions generated
during a specified period.
\[ \text{Absolute Emissions} = \text{Total GHG
Emissions} \]
Emission intensity
Emission intensity measures emissions relative to an economic or physical
activity.
\[ \text{Emission Intensity} = \frac{\text{Total GHG
Emissions}}{\text{Output or Revenue}} \]
Table 9. Illustrative Analysis of Emission Intensity and Absolute Emissions
|
Indicator |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
|
Production |
10 million tonnes |
12 million tonnes |
|
Absolute emissions |
8 million tonnes CO₂e |
8.4 million tonnes CO₂e |
|
Emissions per tonne of output |
0.80 tonnes CO₂e |
0.70 tonnes CO₂e |
|
Absolute emissions change |
— |
+5% |
|
Emission intensity change |
— |
−12.5% |
Source: Hypothetical illustration prepared for analytical purposes.
The company has improved its emission intensity by 12.5%, but absolute
emissions have increased by 5%.
This illustrates why emission intensity alone cannot establish whether a
company has reduced its overall contribution to climate change.
7.3 Financial Performance
Carbon reporting may affect financial performance through several
mechanisms.
Table 10. Financial Impacts of Mandatory Carbon Reporting
|
Financial dimension |
Potential positive impact |
Potential negative impact |
|
Operating cost |
Energy savings |
Reporting and consultancy costs |
|
Capital expenditure |
Efficiency-enhancing investments |
High initial technology cost |
|
Revenue |
Improved market access |
Customer loss due to poor ESG performance |
|
Investment |
Greater investor confidence |
Additional assurance expenses |
|
Risk management |
Better identification of climate risks |
Increased compliance obligations |
|
Competitiveness |
Improved resource productivity |
Higher costs for carbon-intensive businesses |
The relationship between carbon reporting and financial performance is
therefore not universally positive.
The financial outcome depends on industry characteristics, the cost of
compliance, the economic benefits of efficiency, and the company's ability to
implement environmental improvements.
7.4 Corporate Performance
Measurement Framework
A company should evaluate its carbon-reporting programme through four
categories of performance indicators.
Table 11. Corporate Carbon Performance Measurement Framework
|
Category |
Key indicators |
|
Disclosure performance |
BRSR completeness, Scope 1 and 2 coverage |
|
Operational performance |
Energy consumption, fuel efficiency, renewable energy share |
|
Environmental performance |
Absolute emissions, emission intensity, emissions avoided |
|
Financial performance |
Energy savings, carbon-related expenditure, return on environmental
investment |
This framework provides a more balanced assessment than measuring the
success of sustainability reporting solely through the publication of annual
reports.
8. Empirical Analysis of Indian
Corporate Carbon Reporting
This section examines published empirical evidence concerning the
development, coverage, and limitations of India's BRSR system.
8.1 Analysis of BRSR Reporting by
Indian Companies
The Indian Institute for Human Settlements examined sustainability
disclosures of 150 listed Indian companies in its 2024 report.
The study demonstrates the importance of examining reporting quality and the
actual usefulness of the data rather than relying exclusively on whether
companies have filed reports.
8.2 Disclosure Trends and Data
Quality
The Council on Energy, Environment and Water's 2026 analysis examined BRSR
submissions across 1,258 companies over FY 2022–23 to FY 2024–25.
The published findings provide important insights into the development of
Indian corporate environmental disclosure.
Table 12. Environmental Disclosure Trends in India
|
Indicator |
FY 2022–23 |
FY 2024–25 |
Interpretation |
|
GHG disclosure rate |
99.8% |
87.6% |
Coverage declined in the studied filing universe |
|
Air pollutant disclosure rate |
90.4% |
70.7% |
Reporting of conventional pollutants weakened |
|
Gap between GHG and air pollutant disclosure |
Approximately 9 percentage points |
Approximately 17 percentage points |
Environmental reporting remains uneven |
Source: CEEW, 2026. These figures relate to the study's respective filing
populations and should not be interpreted as a matched-company longitudinal
panel.
CEEW+1
The figures indicate that a regulatory reporting architecture does not
eliminate all disclosure gaps.
A company may report greenhouse gas emissions while providing incomplete information
about other forms of environmental pollution.
8.3 Analysis of FY 2024–25
Disclosure
CEEW reported the following distribution among 1,222 companies filing BRSR
for FY 2024–25.
Table 13. Environmental Disclosure Distribution
|
Disclosure category |
Companies |
Percentage |
|
Disclosed both air pollutant and GHG data |
823 |
67.4% |
|
Disclosed GHG data only |
247 |
20.2% |
|
Disclosed neither |
111 |
9.1% |
|
Disclosed air pollutant data only |
41 |
3.4% |
|
Total |
1,222 |
100% |
Source: CEEW's published analysis. Percentages are calculated from the
reported company counts and rounded.
The findings indicate that approximately one-fifth of companies reported
greenhouse gas data without reporting corresponding air pollutant data.
This is important because carbon emissions and local air pollution are
associated with different environmental impacts.
A company may demonstrate carbon accountability while providing insufficient
information about pollutants affecting nearby communities.
8.4 Sectoral Disclosure Analysis
The CEEW analysis also found differences across industrial sectors.
CEEW+1
Table 14. Sectoral Environmental Disclosure Comparison
|
Sector |
GHG disclosure |
Air pollutant disclosure |
Analytical interpretation |
|
Manufacturing |
Approximately 91% |
Approximately 91% |
Relatively high disclosure |
|
Financial and insurance |
Approximately 81% |
Approximately 10% |
Low direct pollutant footprint may explain difference |
|
Construction and real estate |
Approximately 81% |
Approximately 68% |
Potentially important reporting gap |
These differences suggest that environmental disclosure should be evaluated
in relation to the actual environmental footprint of each industry.
For example, a financial services company may have limited direct air
emissions. However, a construction company has substantial potential for dust,
particulate matter, and other local pollution.
Therefore, industry-specific materiality is essential for evaluating the
adequacy of corporate reporting.
8.5 Reliability and Comparability of
Data
CEEW found that particulate matter reporting was fragmented across multiple
units, including tonnes, kilograms, milligrams per normal cubic metre, and
parts per million.
This creates difficulties in aggregating and comparing environmental data.
The research also identified instances of zero values or incorrect units.
CEEW+1
The issue demonstrates that data quantity and data quality are different
dimensions of sustainability reporting.
Table 15. Carbon Reporting Data Quality Problems
|
Problem |
Consequence |
|
Different measurement units |
Reduced comparability |
|
Incomplete Scope 3 disclosure |
Inadequate value-chain accountability |
|
Incorrect or unexplained zero values |
Reduced reliability |
|
Different reporting boundaries |
Misleading year-on-year comparisons |
|
Weak assurance |
Increased risk of reporting errors |
|
Inconsistent emission factors |
Difficulty evaluating actual performance |
8.6 Interpretation of Empirical
Results
The empirical evidence supports three major observations.
First, India has developed a substantial corporate sustainability reporting
system.
Second, the quality and completeness of environmental disclosure remain
uneven.
Third, reporting coverage alone is not sufficient to determine whether
companies are reducing emissions.
These observations support the argument that mandatory reporting is an
important foundation for environmental accountability, but it is not a complete
environmental policy instrument.
9. Comparative Analysis of
Energy-Intensive and Non-Energy-Intensive Industries
One of the most important findings of this research is that the
effectiveness of mandatory carbon reporting depends upon the characteristics of
the industry.
9.1 Energy-Intensive Industries
Energy-intensive industries include:
·
Cement.
·
Steel.
·
Aluminium.
·
Thermal power.
·
Fertilisers.
·
Chemicals.
These industries have a direct relationship between energy consumption,
production costs, and emissions.
Carbon reporting may therefore support cost reduction, regulatory
compliance, and operational optimization.
However, absolute emission reductions may be difficult to achieve when
production expands or when the underlying manufacturing process is inherently
carbon-intensive.
9.2 Non-Energy-Intensive Industries
Non-energy-intensive industries include:
·
Information technology.
·
Banking and financial services.
·
Retail.
·
Professional services.
·
Certain consumer-service businesses.
These sectors may have lower direct operational emissions but substantial
indirect emissions.
Their carbon-reporting motivation may be driven by:
·
International clients.
·
Investors.
·
ESG ratings.
·
Corporate reputation.
·
Energy-efficient buildings.
·
Digital infrastructure.
The financial incentives to reduce emissions may be weaker than those in
heavy manufacturing, particularly when electricity expenditure represents a
relatively small proportion of total operating costs.
9.3 Comparative Framework
Table 16. Comparative Analysis of Carbon Reporting Across Indian Industries
|
Dimension |
Energy-intensive industries |
Non-energy-intensive industries |
|
Direct emissions |
High |
Generally lower |
|
Energy cost significance |
High |
Low to moderate |
|
Financial motivation |
Strong |
Moderate or weak |
|
Regulatory motivation |
Strong |
Strong due to BRSR |
|
Reputation motivation |
Strong |
Strong |
|
Scope 3 importance |
Significant |
Often highly significant |
|
Operational efficiency potential |
High |
Moderate |
|
Absolute emission reduction difficulty |
High |
Variable |
|
Main managerial challenge |
Process decarbonization |
Indirect emissions and data boundaries |
The analysis indicates that a uniform reporting requirement can produce
unequal managerial consequences.
Consequently, India's reporting framework should be complemented by
sector-specific performance expectations.
10. Critical Analysis: Why Mandatory
Carbon Reporting May Fail to Reduce Emissions
10.1 Reporting as a Compliance
Exercise
Some companies may approach BRSR as an annual documentation requirement.
Their principal objective may be to:
·
Complete the prescribed format.
·
Avoid regulatory non-compliance.
·
Submit information within the required timeline.
·
Obtain external assistance for preparing the
report.
In such circumstances, reporting may have limited influence on production
decisions, investment allocation, and environmental strategy.
This is consistent with institutional theory, which distinguishes formal
organizational structures from substantive organizational behaviour.
10.2 Greenwashing and Selective
Disclosure
Companies may use sustainability reporting to communicate favourable
environmental information.
The risk arises when the reporting emphasizes achievements but fails to
provide a balanced account of overall performance.
For example, a company may report a renewable energy installation but fail
to explain that its total energy consumption has increased considerably.
Greenwashing may therefore occur not only through false statements but also
through selective presentation and inadequate contextual information.
10.3 Weak Link Between ESG Reporting
and Managerial Incentives
Carbon reporting may not influence managerial decisions if executive
compensation and departmental performance targets are based exclusively on
financial indicators.
For example:
·
Production managers may be rewarded for output.
·
Sales managers may be rewarded for revenue.
·
Finance managers may be rewarded for
profitability.
If carbon intensity and absolute emissions are not incorporated into these
performance systems, sustainability reporting may remain peripheral.
10.4 Scope 3 Measurement
Difficulties
Scope 3 emissions are associated with value-chain activities.
For Indian businesses, these emissions may arise from:
·
Imported raw materials.
·
Supplier manufacturing.
·
Transportation.
·
Employee commuting.
·
Product usage.
·
Waste disposal.
The measurement of Scope 3 emissions requires cooperation from external
organizations.
This is particularly challenging for companies that depend upon a large
network of small and medium enterprises.
10.5 Administrative and Compliance
Costs
Mandatory carbon reporting may impose costs relating to:
·
ESG consultants.
·
Sustainability professionals.
·
Software and data systems.
·
Auditors and assurance providers.
·
Internal coordination.
·
Staff training.
For large companies, these costs may be manageable.
For smaller suppliers and businesses, however, the costs may be
proportionately greater.
This creates a policy challenge: environmental accountability must improve
without imposing unnecessary reporting burdens on smaller enterprises.
10.6 Disclosure Without Absolute
Emission Reduction
The most important limitation of disclosure-based climate governance is that
companies may report improvements in intensity while total emissions continue
to rise.
A growing company may reduce emissions per unit of output but still generate
more emissions overall.
Therefore, absolute emissions, intensity indicators, and operational
performance must be evaluated together.
10.7 Critical Summary
Table 17. Critical Assessment of Mandatory Carbon Reporting
|
Strength |
Limitation |
|
Creates standardized environmental disclosures |
Standardization does not ensure accuracy |
|
Improves corporate transparency |
Transparency does not ensure emission reduction |
|
Supports investor decisions |
Investors may not use all disclosed information |
|
Encourages environmental data systems |
Data systems may be used primarily for compliance |
|
Increases managerial awareness |
Awareness may not lead to investment |
|
Supports reputational accountability |
Can be used for selective image management |
|
Encourages assurance |
Assurance may not cover all material emissions |
The evidence suggests that the success of mandatory carbon reporting should
be judged not by the number of sustainability reports published, but by the
extent to which environmental information influences corporate decisions and
environmental outcomes.
11. Case Study: BRSR and Carbon
Accountability in the Indian Cement Industry
11.1 Industry Background
The cement industry is an important component of India's infrastructure and
economic development.
Cement is required for:
·
Roads.
·
Bridges.
·
Residential construction.
·
Commercial buildings.
·
Industrial infrastructure.
·
Urban development.
However, cement production is associated with substantial greenhouse gas
emissions.
These emissions arise from fuel combustion and the chemical process of
clinker production.
The industry therefore provides an important case for examining the
relationship between carbon reporting, operational efficiency, and
environmental performance.
11.2 BRSR as a Management Tool
A cement company can use BRSR data to identify environmental performance
issues.
For example, a company may examine:
·
Fuel consumption per tonne of cement.
·
Electricity consumption per tonne of cement.
·
Clinker-to-cement ratio.
·
Renewable electricity usage.
·
Waste-heat recovery.
·
Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions.
·
Water consumption.
This information can be incorporated into production planning and capital
budgeting.
11.3 Illustrative Corporate Scenario
Consider a hypothetical Indian cement company.
Table 18. Illustrative Carbon-Reduction Programme
|
Indicator |
Baseline |
Target |
|
Annual cement production |
10 million tonnes |
12 million tonnes |
|
Emission intensity |
0.80 tonnes CO₂e/tonne |
0.70 tonnes CO₂e/tonne |
|
Renewable electricity share |
15% |
30% |
|
Waste-heat recovery |
10% of electricity requirement |
20% |
|
Fuel efficiency |
Baseline |
Improved |
|
Annual carbon disclosure |
Basic |
Assured and detailed |
Source: Hypothetical case scenario developed for analytical illustration;
figures are not actual company disclosures.
The company could implement a programme consisting of:
1. Improved
kiln efficiency.
2. Renewable
electricity procurement.
3. Waste-heat
recovery.
4. Alternative
fuels.
5. Clinker
optimization.
6. Improved
production monitoring.
11.4 Managerial Implications
The case demonstrates that carbon reporting becomes more effective when
linked to:
·
Production targets.
·
Capital expenditure.
·
Cost reduction.
·
Operational performance.
·
Environmental accountability.
·
Executive responsibility.
The reporting system should therefore be integrated into the company's
management control system.
12. Findings of the Study
The research identifies the following findings.
Finding 1: Mandatory reporting has
strengthened corporate sustainability accountability
SEBI's BRSR framework has institutionalized sustainability disclosure for
India's large listed companies.
Environmental information is increasingly incorporated into corporate
reporting.
Finding 2: Regulatory motivation is
a major driver
Companies subject to BRSR are required to disclose prescribed information.
Consequently, regulatory compliance is a fundamental motivation for carbon
reporting.
Finding 3: Financial incentives vary
across industries
Energy-intensive companies have stronger economic incentives to reduce
energy consumption and emissions.
Service-sector companies may be more influenced by investor, client, and
reputational pressures.
Finding 4: Carbon reporting may
improve internal coordination
The preparation of sustainability reports can strengthen collaboration
between finance, operations, procurement, and environmental departments.
However, the extent of this improvement differs across organizations.
Finding 5: Data quality remains an
important concern
Published empirical evidence identifies inconsistencies in environmental
disclosure, including incomplete data and differences in measurement units.
CEEW+1
Finding 6: Reporting does not
automatically produce absolute emission reductions
Companies may improve emission intensity while total emissions continue to
rise.
The distinction between absolute emissions and intensity is therefore
essential.
Finding 7: Assurance can strengthen
credibility
External assurance may improve the reliability of selected indicators, but
its effectiveness depends on the scope, methodology, expertise, and
independence of the assurance provider.
Finding 8: Sector-specific
environmental accountability is necessary
Different industries have different emission profiles and opportunities for
reduction.
Sectoral benchmarks can improve the relevance of carbon reporting.
Finding 9: BRSR should be integrated
with corporate performance management
Environmental information becomes more useful when it influences investment,
production, procurement, and managerial incentives.
Finding 10: India requires a shift
from reporting to performance
The ultimate objective should be measurable environmental improvement, not
simply the publication of sustainability information.
13. Recommendations for Indian
Corporations
13.1 Integrate Carbon Reporting with
Strategic Management
Indian companies should treat carbon reporting as a strategic management
instrument.
Environmental performance should be integrated into:
·
Corporate planning.
·
Capital budgeting.
·
Production management.
·
Procurement.
·
Risk management.
·
Financial reporting.
·
Executive performance evaluation.
13.2 Establish Carbon Accounting
Systems
Companies should develop reliable systems for collecting and consolidating
environmental information.
Such systems should clearly define:
·
Organizational reporting boundaries.
·
Emission sources.
·
Measurement methodologies.
·
Emission factors.
·
Data ownership.
·
Verification procedures.
13.3 Develop Sector-Specific Targets
Carbon targets should reflect the operational characteristics of each
industry.
For example:
·
Cement companies may focus on clinker-related
emissions and fuel efficiency.
·
Steel companies may focus on process efficiency
and cleaner technologies.
·
IT companies may focus on electricity and
data-centre efficiency.
·
Logistics companies may focus on fuel
consumption and transport emissions.
·
Banks may focus on climate-related financial
risks and financed emissions.
13.4 Improve Management
Accountability
Environmental indicators should be incorporated into managerial performance
systems.
Managers should be accountable for both operational and environmental
outcomes.
13.5 Strengthen Scope 3 Reporting
Companies should progressively improve their value-chain data.
Supplier engagement should include:
·
Standardized emission data templates.
·
Supplier training.
·
Emission measurement support.
·
Procurement incentives.
·
Collaborative reduction programmes.
13.6 Improve Environmental Assurance
Assurance should be supported by appropriate expertise and independent
verification.
Companies should avoid treating assurance as a ceremonial exercise.
13.7 Link Sustainability Reporting
with Financial Analysis
Companies should evaluate the financial consequences of carbon-related
investments.
Useful measures include:
·
Energy savings.
·
Carbon-related operating costs.
·
Return on environmental investment.
·
Cost of carbon reduction.
·
Financial exposure to climate risks.
14. Policy Recommendations to SEBI,
BEE, and the Government of India

14.1 Move Beyond Disclosure-Based
Regulation
The primary objective of BRSR should progressively move beyond reporting
completeness towards environmental performance.
Companies should be encouraged to disclose:
·
Baseline emissions.
·
Annual emission changes.
·
Absolute emission targets.
·
Intensity targets.
·
Progress against targets.
·
Reasons for target deviations.
14.2 Standardize Carbon Measurement
SEBI and relevant technical authorities should improve consistency in
measurement.
The framework should specify:
·
Common units.
·
Clear organizational boundaries.
·
Appropriate emission factors.
·
Consistent reporting periods.
·
Transparent treatment of estimates.
·
Clear distinctions between actual reductions and
offsets.
14.3 Establish Sector-Specific
Benchmarks
A common carbon-intensity benchmark may not be appropriate for all
industries.
The government and industry bodies should develop benchmarks for major
sectors such as cement, steel, power, aluminium, chemicals, transportation, and
IT.
14.4 Integrate BRSR with Existing
Regulatory Data
India has several environmental reporting systems.
These include:
·
SEBI's BRSR.
·
BEE's PAT scheme.
·
Carbon Credit Trading Scheme reporting.
·
CPCB and State Pollution Control Board
reporting.
·
Industry-specific environmental reporting.
Greater coordination could reduce duplication and improve data reliability.
14.5 Strengthen Independent
Verification
The credibility of environmental reporting depends upon independent
verification.
Assurance providers should possess suitable technical expertise and should
disclose their methodologies.
14.6 Support Smaller Businesses
Large listed companies should not transfer excessive reporting costs to
small suppliers.
The government should promote:
·
Standardized reporting templates.
·
Affordable carbon-accounting tools.
·
Technical training.
·
Industry-level shared resources.
·
Financial support for efficiency improvements.
14.7 Introduce a
Disclosure-Performance Scorecard
A company-level scorecard could distinguish between the quality of
disclosure and actual environmental performance.
Table 19. Proposed Corporate Carbon Accountability Scorecard
|
Dimension |
Suggested weight |
|
Carbon disclosure completeness |
20% |
|
Data reliability and assurance |
20% |
|
Absolute emission reduction |
25% |
|
Energy efficiency and emission intensity |
15% |
|
Achievement of climate targets |
10% |
|
Integration with corporate strategy |
10% |
|
Total |
100% |
Source: Researcher's proposed framework. The weights are illustrative and
require consultation and empirical validation before regulatory use.
The scorecard would discourage companies from achieving high sustainability
scores solely through extensive reporting.
15. Future Research Directions
Future studies should examine the following areas.
15.1 Quantitative Analysis of BRSR
and Financial Performance
A firm-level panel study could examine the relationship between carbon
reporting and:
·
Return on Assets (ROA).
·
Return on Equity (ROE).
·
Operating margins.
·
Market valuation.
·
Energy expenditure.
·
Carbon intensity.
15.2 Sectoral Research
Separate studies should be conducted for:
·
Cement.
·
Steel.
·
Power.
·
IT services.
·
Banking.
·
Pharmaceuticals.
·
Automobile manufacturing.
15.3 Longitudinal Research
Research should compare company performance over multiple years.
The study should determine whether disclosure improvements are followed by
measurable emission reductions.
15.4 Organizational Behaviour
Research
Interviews with managers, finance professionals, sustainability officers,
and operational personnel could examine whether BRSR has changed corporate
decision-making.
15.5 Greenwashing and Corporate
Disclosure
Future research should assess the relationship between sustainability
communication, environmental performance, and corporate reputation.
15.6 Carbon Reporting and MSMEs
Research should examine how large companies' carbon-reporting requirements
influence small and medium-sized suppliers.
16. Conclusion
Mandatory carbon reporting has become an important component of India's
evolving corporate sustainability governance framework.
SEBI's BRSR regime has established a formal structure for environmental,
social, and governance disclosure among large listed companies. It has
increased the visibility of corporate greenhouse gas emissions and created a
basis for greater environmental accountability.
The present research demonstrates that the influence of carbon reporting
extends beyond annual sustainability reports. It can affect internal
information systems, departmental coordination, corporate strategy, investment
decisions, procurement, energy management, and performance measurement.
However, the effectiveness of reporting depends upon the motivations and
capabilities of individual organizations.
Energy-intensive companies may adopt carbon reporting because environmental
improvements can produce financial savings. Service-sector companies may be
more influenced by investor expectations, customer requirements, and corporate
reputation. Regulatory compliance remains a major motivation across both
categories.
The Indian empirical evidence also reveals important limitations. Reporting
quality remains uneven, environmental data may be difficult to compare, and the
presence of a sustainability report does not necessarily establish that
absolute emissions have declined.
The central conclusion is that mandatory carbon reporting is a
necessary but insufficient condition for corporate decarbonization.
India must move towards a more integrated model of carbon accountability in
which disclosure is linked to operational efficiency, investment decisions,
verified environmental performance, and sector-specific emission-reduction
targets.
The success of corporate climate governance should ultimately be measured
not by how many companies publish sustainability reports, but by how
effectively businesses reduce their environmental impact while maintaining
economic competitiveness.
In this respect, BRSR represents an important institutional foundation. Its
future effectiveness will depend upon the extent to which Indian corporations
transform environmental information into measurable improvements in business
processes, financial efficiency, and environmental performance.
17. References
IEEE Reference Style
[1] P. Bansal and K. Roth, “Why companies go green: A model of ecological
responsiveness,” Academy of Management Journal, vol. 43, no. 4, pp.
717–736, Aug. 2000.
[2] M. E. Porter and C. van der Linde, “Toward a new conception of the
environment-competitiveness relationship,” Journal of Economic Perspectives,
vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 97–118, 1995.
[3] Securities and Exchange Board of India, “Business Responsibility and
Sustainability Report (BRSR),” Circular No. SEBI/HO/CFD/CMD-2/P/CIR/2021/562,
May 10, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.sebi.gov.in/
[4] Securities and Exchange Board of India, “BRSR Core—Framework for
assurance and ESG disclosures for value chain,” Circular No. SEBI/HO/CFD/CFD-SEC-2/P/CIR/2023/122,
Jul. 12, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.sebi.gov.in/legal/circulars/jul-2023/brsr-core-framework-for-assurance-and-esg-disclosures-for-value-chain_73854.html
[5] S. Guruprasad, A. B. Bazaz, M. Dubey, N. Choudhary, H. B. N. Harshith,
V. Ganapathy, and A. Mittal, “Business responsibility and sustainability
reporting in India: An analysis of disclosures from 150 companies,” Indian
Institute for Human Settlements, Nov. 2024. [Online]. Available: https://iihs.co.in/publication/business-responsibility-and-sustainability-reporting-in-india-an-analysis-of-disclosures-from-150-companies/
[6] CFA Institute and CFA Society India, “The current state of BRSR at
corporate India,” 2024. [Online]. Available: https://rpc.cfainstitute.org/research/reports/2024/the-current-state-of-brsr-at-corporate-india
[7] CFA Institute and CFA Society India, “The current state of BRSR in
corporate India 2.0,” Jun. 2026. [Online]. Available: https://rpc.cfainstitute.org/research/reports/2026/current-state-brsr-corporate-india
[8] S. Verma, S. Patra, and P. Borah, “Strengthening air emissions
disclosures in ESG reporting: Review of India's BRSR and global regulatory
frameworks,” Council on Energy, Environment and Water, New Delhi, Jul. 16,
2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.ceew.in/publications/air-emission-reporting-brsr-esg-frameworks
[9] Securities and Exchange Board of India, “Frequently asked
questions/general observations and guidelines on filing of Business
Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR/BRSR Core),” 2024. [Online].
Available: https://www.sebi.gov.in/
[10] Greenhouse Gas Protocol, Corporate Accounting and Reporting
Standard. World Resources Institute and World Business Council for
Sustainable Development, 2004. [Online]. Available: https://ghgprotocol.org/
[11] A. B. Carroll, “The pyramid of corporate social responsibility: Toward
the moral management of organizational stakeholders,” Business Horizons,
vol. 34, no. 4, pp. 39–48, Jul.–Aug. 1991.
[12] M. E. Clarkson, “A stakeholder framework for analyzing and evaluating
corporate social performance,” Academy of Management Review, vol. 20,
no. 1, pp. 92–117, Jan. 1995.
[13] M. E. Porter and M. R. Kramer, “Strategy and society: The link between
competitive advantage and corporate social responsibility,” Harvard
Business Review, vol. 84, no. 12, pp. 78–92, Dec. 2006.
[14] P. M. Deegan, “Introduction: The legitimising effect of social and
environmental disclosures—A theoretical foundation,” Accounting, Auditing
& Accountability Journal, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 282–311, 2002.
[15] S. DiMaggio and W. W. Powell, “The iron cage revisited: Institutional
isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields,” American
Sociological Review, vol. 48, no. 2, pp. 147–160, Apr. 1983.

No comments:
Post a Comment