label

(Jaago Re Campaign) (1) 11 Ps and lord Ganesha (1) 129 (1) 2026-28 (1) 3 E's (1) 7.6 (1) 9 (1) Academic management (1) acquisitions strategic investment (1) advertising (1) agreement (1) Agri and human health (1) agriculture and war (1) agriculture distress (1) agriculture export (1) AI (1) ajit pawar (1) AL and corporate decision (1) AMERICA (1) America new Act (1) Amozon (1) AMUL (2) and limitations (1) Animal export (1) Antidumping globalized economies (1) apna sweet (1) Areca nuts (1) arms (1) art culture and technology (1) Assam (1) ASTROLOGY (1) Automobiles (1) Automotive (1) aviation (1) baby products (1) Back cover page (3) bangle (1) BANK (1) banking (1) before 1947 (1) bhagat singh (1) BI VS BA (1) bicycle (1) Biofuels (1) biscuits (1) biscuits industry (1) BMW'S premium automotive and motorcycle industry (CASE STUDY ) (1) BOP (1) boroplus (1) BRAIN DRAIN (1) brand (1) brand management and market organization (1) Brand positioning and Ganesha (1) break (1) BRICS (1) budget 2026 (1) bullet (1) CAG (1) cake & bread (1) car (1) cartelization (1) case cum research (2) case cum research paper (2) case study (4) case study based on britannia (1) case study based on pharmaceutical industry (1) case study blog on (5) case study blog on cooking oil brands (1) case study blog on divine copper (1) case study blog on health drink brand (1) case study blog on papad brand (1) case study blog on salespersons (1) case study blog on shipping charges (1) case study blog on spices export (1) case study blog on supply chain management (1) case study cum research (4) case study cum research work on R&D and Gross expenditure (1) case study for infosys (1) case study Hindustan zinc limited (1) CASE STUDY IN FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (1) case study in international finance (1) CASE STUDY KRBL limited (1) case study of HR (1) case study of pepsi-co INDIA (1) case study on (4) case study on brand Surf Excel (1) case study on venus industrial corporation (1) case study on advertisement management (1) CASE STUDY ON ADVERTIZEMENT (1) case study on agar batti (1) CASE STUDY ON Ambuja Cements and Orient Cement. (1) case study on Automotive Industry (1) case study on bata (1) case study on Bijur Sooper foods pvt.ltd (1) case study on britannia (1) case study on campa cola (1) case study on coco-cola (1) case study on cunsumer goods (1) case study on Dabur (1) case study on Dhruv Rathee vs Real juice (1) case study on Economic policy (1) case study on economics (1) case study on export (1) case study on export company (1) CASE STUDY ON FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (1) case study on FMCG (1) CASE STUDY ON FOOTWEAR BRAND (1) case study on godrej (1) CASE STUDY ON HFCL (1) case study on HONDA (1) case study on hotels (1) CASE STUDY ON HR (4) case study on HR mana (1) case study on HR management (1) CASE STUDY ON HUL (1) case study on human resources management (1) case study on India's Tile industry (1) case study on Indian cosmetics (1) case study on indian khadi (1) case study on Indigo paints (1) case study on industry 4.0 (1) case study on international marketing (1) case study on kia brand (1) case study on kinetic green (1) case study on kiran gems (1) case study on LAKME COSMETICS (1) case study on lord Ganesha's teaching and corporate world (1) CASE STUDY ON MAHALAXMI UTENSIL PVT LIMITED (1) case study on marketing (2) case study on marketing strategies (1) case study on Maruti Suzuki (1) case study on matchbox (1) case study on media management (1) case study on MNC's (1) CASE STUDY ON MRF VS APOLLO TYRES (1) case study on Nestle India (1) case study on old washing powder journey (1) case study on operation management (1) CASE STUDY ON Parle-G (1) case study on peter England (1) case study on Pratibha Syntex (1) case study on product failure (1) CASE STUDY ON PUBLIC SECTOR ENTERPRISE (1) case study on Rajvir industries ltd (1) case study on s kumars (1) case study on SACCHI MILK VS. MOTHER DAIRY: (1) case study on Samsung electronics (HRM CASE) (1) case study on Shakti pumps (1) case study on Sony's (1) case study on SpiceJet's challenges and recovery (1) CASE STUDY ON STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT (1) case study on sun pharma (1) CASE STUDY ON TATA TEA BRAND (1) CASE STUDY ON TCS (1) case study on tech mahindra (1) case study on toothpaste brands (1) case study on Trent limited (1) case study on ultra tech cement (1) CASE STUDY ON USHA INTERNATIONAL (1) case study on voltas limited (1) case study on zandu emami (1) case study related to calculation of the inflation rate (1) case study strategic management (1) centralized service (1) chatgpt (1) chemicals (1) chilli (1) china (3) china economy (1) chocolate (1) cinema & operation (1) CIRCULAR ECONOMY (1) clay (1) clean hands (1) cleaning (1) cleaning management (1) client states (1) climate issues and economy (1) CLOSING REMARKS (1) coal (1) code of commerce (1) cold Air (1) colonial oil (1) communication & Ganesha (1) competitive market and Grocery retail (1) conclusion (2) conjunction (1) consumer behaviors reserach (1) consumer marketing tactics (1) consumer motivation (1) consumer satisfaction (1) COO and GMS (1) cooler (1) cooling choices (1) copper (1) corporate cum economic model (1) corporate performance (1) corporate world -2026 (1) COSMETICS (1) COTTON (2) crack (1) creator (1) credos (1) crew crisis (1) crises and calm (1) crisis (1) crisis Economics (1) critical skill (1) CRL (1) customer engagement and grocery retail (1) CUSTOMER MANAGEMENT (1) cut and sew (1) cyber security (1) DA /SR/CW (1) Dalda (1) data analysis (2) davv (1) dead skin (1) defect (1) defense sector (1) delivery (1) Demand & Supply Introduction (1) Demand Forecating (1) Detergent powder (2) developing spectrum (1) dharma (1) digital addiction (1) Digital DARSHAN & OPERATION (1) digital gold (1) digital influence (1) digital infrastructure (1) Diwali (1) doller (1) domestic infrastructure (1) donation (1) doors and windows (1) DPI (1) drama of stones and stories (1) DTC (1) dusting powder (1) Ears and Eyes (1) eating animal (1) Eco -friendly strategies (1) Eco hr research paper (1) ECO MANAGEMENT (2) ecology (1) economic cycle (1) economic management (2) Economic power (1) Economics and Ethology (1) Economy (1) Education strategy (1) Elasticity of DEMAND (1) elderly care (1) Electric managemen (1) electricity (1) Electronics (1) electronics marketing (1) ELSE (1) employment (1) Employment centre (1) Employment management (1) Energy security (1) EPVS DN (1) Ethics and Profit (1) Ethological roots (1) Ethology as a lens (1) EU VS INDIA (1) Exit strategy (1) expanding the case study to research paper (3) expanding the case study to research paper on Demographic trends (1) export brass and silver (1) export import (1) Export import trends (1) external sector (1) eye drop (1) fabric management (1) failure anlysis (1) false promotion (1) fariyali (1) farmers (1) fashion (1) fashion and apparel (1) fast food (1) fd (1) FDI (3) fertilizers (1) Festival (1) festivals ops & operation (1) films (1) Finance and Ethology (1) financial accounting (1) financial analytics (1) financial annuity (1) FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND GROCERY RETAIL (1) fiscal deficit (1) five eyes (1) flowers (1) flying car (1) FMCG (2) FMCG products (1) FOOD GRAINS (1) food mixer (1) Forced Retirement (1) franchise strategy (1) future of OM (1) Ganesha and operation management (1) Ganga jal (1) garland (1) GBOP (1) Gen Z (1) general management (1) ghusapaithi (1) gift (1) global connectivity (1) Global fashion (1) Global Growth (1) Global Production Networks (1) Global Psycology (1) global story (1) GLOBAL TRADE (1) Global vision (1) Godrej Agrovet Limited (GAVL) case study (1) gold and silver (1) Government schemes strategy (1) Grocery Retail and crises management (1) grocery shopping (1) GST and GDP (1) GST reforms (1) gulab jal (1) hand written (1) HDFC (1) health (1) health care management (1) heritage (1) holi (1) hospital (1) Household Financial Behavior (1) housing model (1) HR -FMCG industries (1) HR & marketing mix (1) HR Department 2026 (1) Hr TRENDS (1) HUMAN BEING (1) Hybrid work models (1) I B CT (1) ice cubes (1) IEM (1) illegal wildlife (1) IMF & World Bank (1) Import management (1) imported (1) independence day (1) INDIA & USA (1) india vs japan (1) Indian corporations and economic inequality (1) indian economy (2) Indian painting (1) indonesia (1) inflation (2) inflation rate (1) information age (1) infrastructure (1) ink & Analytics (1) innovation (1) international business (1) International business & Ethology (1) international economics (1) International expansion and cultural framework (1) interview (1) iphone17 (1) IPL strategy (1) ironing (1) isolation and intellect (1) IT & strategic management (1) job layoffs (1) juices (1) kalonji (1) kashmir (1) kavadia yatra (1) kitchen appliances (1) kitchens (1) korea (1) la nina (1) labor relation management (1) ladakh (1) law of demand (1) leadership (1) leadership and world of work (1) learn more aboout the Galeries Lafayette (1) learn more about honey brand (1) letter to child (1) letter to son from father (1) life management (2) light (1) Literature Review (4) local to global (1) location and grocery shop (1) loddo (1) LPG (1) LR and Ethological (1) M&A (1) make in India (1) mango (2) mantra (1) market equilibrium (1) Market share analysis (1) marketing (1) marketing and 2026 (1) Marketing Audit and product performance (1) Marketing Profitability and Financial Performance (1) marketing research (1) marketing strategies (2) MBA (1) mechnical management (1) medicine (2) melody to market (1) mental health (1) METALS (1) methai and TQM (1) microsoft (1) mid career (1) MII (1) milk products (1) Modak's and Milestones (1) MODEL MBA SYLLABUS (1) modern life (1) Modern management thoughts (1) monetary policy (1) mother (1) motivation strategies and employee performance (1) MOU 'S CASE STUDY (1) MOUs (1) Mouse and the mind (1) MT& IM (1) Myanmar (1) NALANDA (1) Namkeen (1) Neem Tree (1) nepal (2) networking (1) NEURALINK (1) Neuromarketing (1) new degree (1) New order (1) new zealand (1) North EAST (1) ODOP (1) oil and gas (1) old people (1) OMC (1) on Aegis logistics ltd (1) onion (1) online shopping (1) OPEC (1) operation & supply chain (1) operation management strategies (1) operation of political parties (1) operational and financial research (1) operations and faith (1) Organizational Behavior and Ethology (1) organizational structure (1) packaging (1) PACKAGING ECONOMICS (1) PAIN KILLER (1) palm oil (1) parents (1) PASTE (1) patanjali (1) patriot bataries (1) peacock (1) Pears soap (1) Ph.d process (1) pharma (2) pharma management and AL (1) pharma products (1) pickles (1) plant food sticks (1) PLASTICS (1) poem in management (1) poha (1) polymer currency (1) POPULATION (1) Positive feedback and NPD (1) PPP (1) price & origin (1) price hikes (1) price wars (1) PRICING STRATEGY AND GROCERY RETAIL (1) Private MBA colleges (1) product brand management (1) product development and advertisement (1) product strategy and Grocery retail (1) promotion (1) protein powder (1) PSYCHOLOGICAL MANAGEMENT (1) public policy control (1) publication house (1) puja (1) quality management (1) railway (1) railway sleeper (1) Rajdoot motorcycles (1) Ratna Mandis -Global MNCs (1) REAL ESTATE (1) Real GDP growth (1) REAL JUICE (1) Realist Analysis (1) Recommendations (1) Red stone (1) Research & Development (1) research anlysis (1) research cum case (1) research cum case study (1) Research cum case study on (1) research cum case study on goverenment expenditure (1) RESEARCH HAIR COLOUR (1) research in marketing (3) Research on digital finance (1) research on gold (1) research on Human management (1) research paper (8) research paper on Global inflation trends (1) research paper on haldi (1) research paper an extension of case study (2) research paper an extension of case study on inflation (1) research paper an extension of case study on TQM (1) research paper Engineering management (1) research paper in operation management (1) research paper is an extension of a case study on the product life cycle (1) Research paper on agriculture Engineering (1) research paper on balance score card (1) Research paper on BCG Matrix (1) research paper on bugget (1) Research paper on consumer strategy (1) RESEARCH PAPER ON EDUCATION STRATEGY (1) research paper on finance (1) RESEARCH PAPER ON FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (1) research paper on Gig Economy (1) RESEARCH PAPER ON GLOBAL OUTLOOK (1) RESEARCH PAPER ON GLOBAL TRADE (1) research paper on India's Textile Exports (1) Research paper on IT PART 2 (1) research paper on IT sector (1) research paper on Neuromarketing (1) research paper on non tariff measures (1) research paper on welfare economics (1) research study (1) Reservation (1) Residential (1) retail marketing (2) river (1) RM & DI (1) RMG (1) Rozgar Mela (1) RRA (1) RSS& BD (1) RTA /DS (1) RTI (1) Rudraksha (1) ruler mistakes and economic breakdown (1) rural business opration (1) rural marketing (1) sale (1) sales management (1) same price (1) samosa (1) SDR (1) service provider and marketing strategies (1) service sector (1) shampoo vs soap (1) sharing transport (1) SIP (1) smuggling (1) social cost (1) social engineering (1) solid waste management (1) south Africa (1) south china sea (1) SPICE (1) spirituality in corporate sector (1) SRILANKA (1) SRL /DS (1) stagflation (1) startup (1) Stomach problem management (1) stories -operation (1) strategic historical (1) strategic management (1) strategic model (1) strategic orientations and culture intelligence (1) strategic partnership (1) strategies (1) strategy (2) strategy in FMCG companies (1) street vendors operation (1) stress management (1) students (2) success story -case study (1) suggestions and limitations (1) super cycle (1) supply (1) supply chain (1) supply chain and Ashrams (1) sweet (1) tablets (1) tamaku Tabacco brand (1) Tariffs (1) tax (1) tea (1) tech talent (1) technology servics (1) television (1) Temple operations (1) textile (1) textile and handicraft (1) textile- IBP (1) thermometre (1) time management (1) tools in research (1) toothpaste (1) Town planning (1) traiff (1) trap (1) tribute to great leader (1) tribute to Ratan tata (1) Turbines (1) TVS (1) two wheeler (1) unemployment (1) unemployment and brand (1) UPVS MP (1) uranium (1) urban company (1) utencils (1) variety and value (1) vedanta (1) veg /non veg (1) venezuela (1) veto power (1) VISAKHAPATNAM (1) visual vs content (1) vs INDIA (1) WAR (1) waste cloths (1) watch /mobile (1) WATER (1) we (1) weapons (1) wedding & OM (1) west Bengal (1) wind turbine (1) women (2) word of mouth & 11'ps (1) workplace management (1) world balance sheet (1) world map (1) x vs z (1) youth unemployment (1)

Thursday, November 19, 2026

CRITICAL RESEARCH EVALUATION AI-Source Disclosure in Second-Hand Product Descriptions: Diagnosticity, Trust, and Purchase Intention

 

CRITICAL RESEARCH EVALUATION

AI-Source Disclosure in Second-Hand Product Descriptions: Diagnosticity, Trust, and Purchase Intention

 


Original Journal: Journal of Marketing Management

Original Article: Easy listing, hard selling? How AI-source disclosure in second-hand product descriptions shapes purchase intention

Original Authors: Jianming Wang, Wenxuan Ru, and Guotao Ye

Publication year: 2026 | Published online: 9 November 2026

Original DOI as supplied: https://doi.org/10.1080/0267257X.2026.2760826

 

Prepared by

Dr. Mamta Vyas

Independent Researcher – Management and Economics


 

Abstract

Background: Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used to prepare product descriptions in consumer-to-consumer (C2C) second-hand marketplaces. Although AI-assisted content can reduce listing effort and improve presentation, disclosure of AI involvement may affect consumers’ perceptions of information usefulness and seller credibility.

Methods: This critical evaluation examines the original study by Wang, Ru, and Ye (2026), which reports four online experiments comparing AI-source and seller-source disclosure across second-hand and primary markets. The original research considers perceived information diagnosticity and seller trust as sequential mediators, product type as a moderator, and proofreading disclosure and seller review as mitigating conditions. The present paper critically evaluates the theoretical framework, experimental approach, interpretation, and implications without reconstructing unavailable numerical results.

Results: The original study reports that AI-source disclosure reduces purchase intention in second-hand markets but not in primary markets. The effect is sequentially mediated by perceived information diagnosticity and trust in sellers, is stronger for experience than search products, and is attenuated when AI is disclosed as proofreading assistance or when the seller reviews AI-generated descriptions.

Conclusion: The research highlights a context-sensitive transparency problem. AI can make listings easier to prepare, but disclosure may reduce perceived diagnosticity and seller trust when buyers depend on item-specific information. Further validation using marketplace behaviour, transparent reporting of experimental details, and cross-platform research is required.

Keywords: generative AI; AI disclosure; second-hand markets; information diagnosticity; seller trust; purchase intention

1. Introduction

Generative artificial intelligence is changing the way commercial information is produced and communicated. Sellers can use AI systems to draft product descriptions, organize specifications, improve grammar, translate listings, and generate promotional language. These capabilities can lower the time and skill required to create online listings and may be especially useful to small sellers and individuals who lack professional marketing resources.

However, the use of AI also raises questions about transparency, authenticity, credibility, and accountability. Consumers may evaluate a message not only by its content but also by the source they believe produced it. Disclosure of AI involvement can therefore become a marketplace cue that shapes how consumers interpret the description and the seller.

This issue is particularly important in C2C second-hand markets. Used products vary in condition, wear, maintenance, repair history, and remaining useful life. Buyers often cannot inspect an item physically before purchase and depend on seller-provided descriptions, photographs, ratings, and responses to questions. In this setting, the description is not merely promotional; it is a source of transaction-specific information that helps reduce uncertainty.

Wang, Ru, and Ye [1] examine whether AI-source disclosure affects purchase intention differently in second-hand and primary markets. Their study proposes that AI disclosure reduces perceived information diagnosticity and subsequently weakens trust in sellers. The effect is reported to be stronger for experience products than search products and less pronounced when AI is used only for proofreading or when the seller reviews the generated content.

The present paper critically evaluates this contribution. It considers the theoretical logic, methodological transparency, statistical interpretation, alternative explanations, managerial relevance, and future research requirements.

1.1 Research problem

The central problem is a potential tension between listing efficiency and consumer confidence. AI can improve the speed and presentation of product information, but consumers may infer that AI-generated descriptions are generic, insufficiently grounded in the item’s actual condition, or less indicative of seller knowledge. Whether such inferences occur—and whether they influence purchase intention—may depend on marketplace context.

1.2 Objectives

1.      Examine the reported effect of AI-source disclosure on purchase intention in second-hand and primary markets.

2.      Evaluate perceived information diagnosticity and seller trust as proposed explanatory mechanisms.

3.      Assess product type as a boundary condition.

4.      Evaluate proofreading disclosure and seller verification as mitigating conditions.

5.      Critically assess the research design, evidence, generalizability, and implications.

1.3 Research questions

6.      Does AI-source disclosure influence purchase intention differently in second-hand and primary markets?

7.      How do perceived information diagnosticity and seller trust explain the reported disclosure effect?

8.      Does product type change the strength of the relationship?

9.      Can disclosure framing and seller verification reduce negative consumer reactions?

10.  How far can experimental findings be generalized to actual marketplace behaviour?

2. Literature Review, Theoretical Development and Hypotheses

2.1 Generative AI disclosure and consumer response in digital markets

Generative AI has expanded the scale and speed of commercial content creation. AI-assisted systems can produce product descriptions, advertisements, promotional messages, and customer communication. Yet disclosure of AI involvement introduces source information that consumers may use when evaluating the message. AI disclosure may signal efficiency and technological capability, but it may also activate concerns about authenticity, credibility, effort, or the extent of human involvement.

The literature does not support a simple universal effect. Consumer responses may depend on the communication context, content type, perceived quality, and the role AI performs. In second-hand marketplaces, product descriptions are expected to convey item-specific information rather than merely persuade consumers about a standardized brand offering. This makes the context materially different from many conventional advertising settings.

The original study [1] extends the AI-disclosure discussion into C2C second-hand transactions and proposes that disclosure may backfire when consumers depend on seller-provided descriptions to assess a used item. The critical implication is that disclosure should be studied as a context-dependent cue, not as an invariant treatment.

2.2 AI disclosure, credibility and authenticity

Credibility concerns whether information is considered believable and reliable; authenticity concerns whether communication appears genuine and connected to the source. These constructs are related but distinct. A message may appear professionally written while consumers remain uncertain whether it accurately represents a particular product. Conversely, a personal description may seem authentic but contain inaccurate details.

AI disclosure can alter source evaluations, but consumers may also react to assumptions about AI capability and content quality. The effects of disclosure should therefore be separated from the effects of the description’s factual accuracy, specificity, readability, and completeness. For second-hand listings, the relevant question is whether AI-produced content provides useful, item-specific evidence.

2.3 Information diagnosticity in second-hand e-commerce

Information diagnosticity refers to the perceived usefulness of information for evaluating a product, comparing alternatives, and making a confident decision. Second-hand products are heterogeneous because their condition depends on use, maintenance, repairs, storage, and ownership history. General product specifications may be insufficient; buyers also need details about defects, wear, accessories, functional condition, and other attributes of the particular item.

AI-generated descriptions may be perceived as less diagnostic if consumers believe they are generic or not grounded in direct inspection. However, AI could also improve diagnosticity when it organizes detailed seller inputs and prompts sellers to disclose relevant condition information. The critical issue is not AI authorship by itself, but whether the content is perceived as accurate, specific, and useful.

2.4 Seller trust and transaction risk

Trust is central to online transactions where buyers cannot fully verify quality before purchase. In C2C settings, consumers may infer seller reliability from ratings, communication, transaction history, disclosure of defects, responsiveness, and the consistency of descriptions with photographs. AI disclosure could weaken trust if buyers infer limited seller effort or product knowledge. Alternatively, responsible AI use could enhance professionalism if the seller verifies the information.

Trust should not be treated as a single undifferentiated construct. Trust in the seller, trust in the description, trust in the platform, and trust in AI may have different antecedents. The original model focuses on seller trust, but future work could separate these dimensions.

2.5 Sequential relationship between diagnosticity, trust and purchase intention

The original paper proposes that AI-source disclosure first reduces perceived information diagnosticity, which then weakens trust in sellers and ultimately lowers purchase intention. This sequence is plausible: consumers may question whether a description is useful for evaluating the actual item and then infer that the seller is less knowledgeable, involved, or reliable. However, mediation alone does not prove temporal or causal ordering. Diagnosticity and trust may be assessed simultaneously or influence one another. Stronger tests would manipulate diagnosticity and seller verification, measure mediators at separate points, and compare alternative mediation models.

2.6 Product type: search and experience products

Search products contain attributes that can often be assessed before purchase, whereas experience products contain characteristics that are more difficult to evaluate without use. Used products may combine both attribute types. For example, technical specifications of a used laptop may be observable, but battery performance, reliability, and condition may remain uncertain. The original study reports a stronger negative disclosure effect for experience products. This is plausible where consumers depend on subjective or difficult-to-verify information, but product classification should be validated and ideally measured continuously through perceived uncertainty or experientiality.

2.7 Disclosure framing and human involvement

AI can generate an entire description, proofread seller-written text, organize supplied information, or assist with translation. These functions differ in human control and accountability. Proofreading disclosure may imply that the seller supplied the substance and used AI to improve presentation. Seller review may signal that the final description was checked against the product. Such cues could mitigate concerns about generic or inaccurate content. However, a verification label is meaningful only when review is substantive; superficial approval may not improve information quality.

2.8 Critical synthesis

The literature and original study raise four central issues: source effects must be distinguished from content-quality effects; trust is multidimensional; experimental purchase intention may differ from real behaviour; and human involvement may operate through accuracy, effort, accountability, or credibility rather than a single pathway. The original framework is valuable because it integrates diagnosticity and seller trust, but it could be expanded to examine authenticity, perceived seller effort, AI familiarity, platform trust, and perceived risk.

2.9 Research gaps and contribution

11.  Context gap: AI-disclosure effects in second-hand markets may differ from primary retail because listings provide item-specific information.

12.  Mechanism gap: the causal ordering and distinctiveness of diagnosticity and seller trust require stronger testing.

13.  Product gap: search-versus-experience classifications may oversimplify products that contain both attribute types.

14.  Disclosure gap: full generation, proofreading, seller editing, and verification are not equivalent disclosure conditions.

15.  Behavioural gap: intention-based experiments require validation against actual clicks, enquiries, purchases, returns, and transaction outcomes.

16.  Accountability gap: human verification and seller responsibility need operational definitions and evidence of substantive review.

The theoretical contribution is to treat AI-source disclosure as a context-dependent cue whose effects may operate through information usefulness and seller trust, with product type and human involvement as boundary conditions.

3. Theoretical Framework and Hypotheses

3.1 AI-source disclosure and purchase intention

In second-hand markets, consumers rely on listing descriptions to assess product condition and transaction risk. AI disclosure may reduce purchase intention if it creates an inference that descriptions are generic or less connected to seller knowledge. In primary markets, brand, standardized specifications, warranties, and institutional credibility may reduce dependence on seller-authored information. The original study reports a context-specific effect.

H1: AI-source disclosure reduces purchase intention in second-hand markets, while its effect is weaker or insignificant in primary markets.

3.2 Perceived information diagnosticity

When AI disclosure leads consumers to perceive descriptions as less specific or useful for evaluating the item, purchase intention may decline. This mechanism depends on consumer inference and is not inevitable; accurate, detailed AI-assisted content may instead increase diagnosticity.

H2: AI-source disclosure negatively influences purchase intention through reduced perceived information diagnosticity.

3.3 Seller trust

Consumers may interpret AI disclosure as evidence of reduced seller involvement, knowledge, or responsibility. Lower trust may reduce willingness to transact. The effect could be reversed where AI use is perceived as professional and verified.

H3: AI-source disclosure negatively influences purchase intention through reduced trust in sellers.

3.4 Sequential mediation

The proposed process begins with consumers’ evaluation of information usefulness and extends to their evaluation of seller reliability. Reduced diagnosticity may create uncertainty about the seller’s knowledge or willingness to provide accurate information, subsequently lowering purchase intention.

H4: The negative effect of AI-source disclosure on purchase intention is sequentially mediated by perceived information diagnosticity and trust in sellers.

3.5 Product type moderation

Experience products may require more subjective, condition-related information than search products. Consumers may consequently be more sensitive to the source of descriptions when evaluating experience products.

H5: The negative effect of AI-source disclosure on purchase intention is stronger for experience products than for search products.

3.6 Proofreading disclosure

Disclosure that AI was used only for proofreading may communicate that the seller remains the source of substantive product information. This may preserve perceptions of seller knowledge and involvement.

H6: The negative effect of AI-source disclosure on purchase intention is weaker when AI is disclosed as being used only for proofreading.

3.7 Seller verification

Seller review may signal accountability and reduce concerns about generic or inaccurate information. Verification may therefore mitigate the negative disclosure effect.

H7: The negative effect of AI-source disclosure on purchase intention is weaker when AI-generated descriptions are reviewed by the seller.

4. Research Methodology

4.1 Research design

The original article reports four online experiments. Based on the article summary supplied for this evaluation, Experiment 1 examines market context (second-hand versus primary); Experiment 2 examines sequential mediation; Experiment 3 examines product type (experience versus search); and Experiment 4 examines disclosure framing, including proofreading-only disclosure and seller review. The experiments use between-subjects comparisons and simulated product listings.

4.2 Participants and sampling

The supplied article summary indicates recruitment through online panels among participants with experience purchasing second-hand products. Participants were randomly assigned to experimental conditions. Exact sample sizes, panel provider, countries, demographics, recruitment dates, exclusion criteria, and cell-level counts were not available in the material supplied for this critical evaluation and should be verified from the full original article before publication.

4.3 Procedure

Participants viewed marketplace-style product listings with manipulated source-disclosure information. They then reported purchase intention and relevant psychological evaluations, including perceived information diagnosticity and seller trust. Manipulation checks were reportedly used to assess recognition of the disclosure conditions. The exact stimuli, wording, order, randomization details, and attention-check procedures require verification from the full paper.

4.4 Measures

The original summary states that established multi-item scales were used for purchase intention, information diagnosticity, and seller trust. Exact item wording, response scales, scale origins, reliability coefficients, and measurement-validation results are not available in the supplied summary. These should be reported precisely in a reproducible manuscript.

4.5 Analytical techniques

The reported analytical approach includes ANOVA for the market-context experiment, bootstrapped serial mediation for the mechanism experiment, moderated mediation for product-type effects, and ANOVA with planned contrasts for disclosure framing. A complete report should provide model specifications, sample sizes, group means, standard deviations, effect sizes, confidence intervals, p-values, assumptions, reliability, and robustness analyses.

4.6 Ethical considerations

The supplied summary states that informed consent and ethical approval were obtained. The ethics committee or institutional review body, approval identifier, consent procedure, compensation, and data-protection arrangements should be reported from the original article. This critical review does not independently verify those details.

5. Results of the Original Study

The results below reproduce the qualitative findings contained in the article summary supplied by the user. Numerical statistics are not added because exact coefficients, sample sizes, confidence intervals, and tables were not available for verification.

5.1 Experiment 1: market-context effect

The original study reports that AI-source disclosure reduced purchase intention in second-hand markets but did not produce a significant negative effect in primary markets. This finding supports the argument that the market context changes the meaning and consequences of AI disclosure.

5.2 Experiment 2: sequential mediation

The study reports that AI disclosure reduced perceived information diagnosticity, which was associated with reduced seller trust and lower purchase intention. The reported sequential indirect effect supports the proposed explanatory pathway, subject to the methodological caveat that mediation results alone do not establish causal ordering.

5.3 Experiment 3: product-type moderation

The negative effect of AI disclosure was reported to be stronger for experience products than for search products. The result is consistent with the proposition that consumers are more sensitive to information source when product evaluation involves experiential uncertainty.

5.4 Experiment 4: disclosure framing

The negative effect was reportedly attenuated when AI was described as being used only for proofreading or when the seller reviewed AI-generated content. This suggests that disclosure framing and human involvement may influence the interpretation of AI-generated descriptions.

5.5 Summary of reported findings

Experiment

Purpose

Qualitative finding reported

1

Market context

Negative effect in second-hand markets; not reported in primary markets

2

Serial mediation

Diagnosticity and seller trust form proposed sequential pathway

3

Product type

Stronger negative effect for experience products

4

Disclosure framing

Proofreading disclosure and seller review attenuate negative effect

6. Discussion and Critical Evaluation

6.1 Theoretical significance

The study’s central contribution is its contextualization of AI disclosure. Rather than treating disclosure as universally beneficial or harmful, it demonstrates—according to the reported findings—that the effect depends on the market setting. The distinction between primary and second-hand markets is theoretically meaningful because the latter places greater emphasis on product-specific seller information.

6.2 Strength of the four-experiment design

The four-experiment sequence is a strength because it addresses the main effect, mechanism, boundary condition, and mitigation strategy in a structured way. Experimental manipulation can provide stronger causal evidence than a single correlational survey. Nonetheless, the credibility of the evidence depends on transparent reporting of stimuli, sample characteristics, manipulation checks, exclusion decisions, and statistical uncertainty.

6.3 Purchase intention versus actual behaviour

Purchase intention is not equivalent to completed purchase. Real transactions are affected by price, availability, urgency, seller ratings, shipping, returns, product photographs, bargaining, and competing listings. A disclosure label may influence stated intention but have a smaller, larger, or different effect on actual conversion. Future studies should examine behavioural outcomes such as click-throughs, enquiries, conversion, selling time, returns, and repeat purchases.

6.4 Source effects versus content-quality effects

A major alternative explanation is that consumers react to assumptions about AI-generated content quality rather than disclosure alone. If AI descriptions are perceived as generic, the disclosure could reduce evaluations even when the text is factually correct. A stronger design would cross authorship disclosure with independently manipulated description quality and specificity, comparing human-written, AI-generated, and human-AI collaborative descriptions.

6.5 Sample and external validity

Online-panel participants and simulated listings may not represent the diversity of actual second-hand buyers. Generalizability depends on country, platform experience, age, digital literacy, AI familiarity, product category, and cultural expectations about human communication. The full original paper should be consulted for sample composition and contextual details.

6.6 Construct validity and measurement transparency

Diagnosticity, credibility, authenticity, seller trust, platform trust, and trust in AI are related but distinct. The original model would be strengthened by reporting discriminant validity and comparing alternative models. Exact item wording, reliability coefficients, factor loadings, and measurement-validation procedures are necessary for replication.

6.7 Mediation and causal ordering

The serial pathway is theoretically plausible, but measured mediators may not establish that diagnosticity precedes seller trust. Consumers may infer trust and information usefulness jointly or reciprocally. Future experiments could manipulate diagnosticity and verification independently, temporally separate measures, and test competing mediation structures.

6.8 Product classification

Search and experience product classifications can be ambiguous. A product may have observable specifications but uncertain performance or condition after prior use. Future work should use multiple product categories and measure experientiality, product uncertainty, and perceived risk directly rather than relying only on binary categorization.

6.9 Human verification and accountability

The reported mitigation from seller review is practically relevant, but verification needs a precise definition. Review may mean checking factual accuracy, editing language, confirming condition, or merely approving a draft. Platform systems should require meaningful confirmation and provide traceable seller accountability. A disclosure label should not imply verification that did not occur.

6.10 Overall critical assessment

The study is timely, conceptually coherent, and practically relevant. Its multi-experiment approach and integration of diagnosticity and trust are notable strengths. Its conclusions should, however, be interpreted within the limits of experimental scenarios and purchase-intention measures. The strongest next step is external validation through real transactions and designs that separate source, content quality, human effort, and verification.

7. Managerial and Platform Implications

7.1 Platform listing tools

Platforms should design AI-assisted listing systems to collect product-specific facts before generating text. Prompts should request age, usage, defects, repairs, accessories, functional condition, and other relevant information. AI should organize and clarify supplied information rather than invent missing details.

7.2 Human review and seller responsibility

Sellers should review generated descriptions against the actual item and confirm factual accuracy. Platforms should distinguish proofreading, drafting, and substantive generation and should not treat a generic ‘seller reviewed’ label as proof of accurate inspection.

7.3 Disclosure design

Disclosure should accurately describe the role AI played. Clear distinctions between AI-generated, AI-assisted, AI-proofread, and seller-verified content may provide more useful information than a single undifferentiated label. Transparency should not be weakened to avoid a negative response; it should be made informative and paired with accountability.

7.4 Seller education

Training should emphasize that AI can improve clarity and presentation but cannot independently verify an item’s condition unless reliable evidence and appropriate systems are supplied. Sellers should disclose defects and avoid unsupported claims.

7.5 Consumer protection

Platforms should monitor AI-assisted listings for fabricated specifications, misleading condition statements, unsupported authenticity claims, and inconsistent descriptions. Consumer trust depends on accurate information and effective remedies, not merely polished language.

8. Implications for Indian E-Commerce

The findings may be relevant to India's expanding online resale, refurbished-goods, social-commerce, and informal marketplace ecosystems. AI-assisted tools could reduce language barriers and improve listing quality for small sellers, individuals, and micro-enterprises. At the same time, consumer trust may depend on photographs, seller communication, ratings, payment protections, return arrangements, and the specificity of product condition disclosures.

A replication in India should examine regional-language listings, urban-rural differences, consumer AI literacy, platform familiarity, age, price sensitivity, seller reputation, and cash-on-delivery or return preferences. The original findings should not be assumed to generalize directly to Indian consumers without data.

8.1 Proposed India-focused research

A future study could compare AI disclosure across electronics, apparel, furniture, books, vehicles, and refurbished devices. It could recruit marketplace users from multiple cities and use both survey experiments and platform behavioural data. The sample size should be established through power analysis; the study should preregister hypotheses and disclose all exclusions and measures.

9. Limitations

17.  The present critical evaluation is based on the article summary supplied by the user and publicly indexed summary material; the full article’s statistical tables were not independently inspected.

18.  Exact experiment sample sizes, demographics, stimuli, scale items, reliability estimates, effect sizes, and confidence intervals are not reproduced here.

19.  The original study’s experimental purchase-intention findings may not directly predict real marketplace behaviour.

20.  The proposed mechanisms may be affected by alternative explanations, including perceived seller effort, authenticity, AI competence, accountability, and perceived risk.

21.  Product-type distinctions may be imperfect because many products combine search and experience attributes.

22.  The original results require replication across countries, platforms, product categories, and consumer groups.

10. Future Research

23.  Field experiments using actual marketplace listings and transaction outcomes.

24.  Crossed manipulations of AI disclosure, content quality, factual specificity, and human verification.

25.  Separate measurement of seller trust, information trust, platform trust, and trust in AI.

26.  Cross-cultural and India-specific replication studies.

27.  Longitudinal studies of repeated exposure to AI-assisted listings and consumer learning.

28.  Investigation of price, seller reputation, product risk, return policy, and photographs as moderators.

29.  Tests of different disclosure formats and verification procedures.

30.  Research on AI disclosure effects on seller outcomes, including listing completion, time-to-sale, bargaining, and returns.

11. Conclusion

The original research by Wang, Ru, and Ye [1] addresses an important emerging issue in digital commerce: AI can make product listings easier to prepare, but disclosure of AI involvement may affect consumers’ evaluation of information and sellers. The reported findings indicate that AI-source disclosure reduces purchase intention in second-hand markets but not primary markets, with the effect operating through perceived information diagnosticity and seller trust. The negative effect is reported to be stronger for experience products and attenuated by proofreading disclosure or seller review.

The critical evaluation concludes that the study offers a valuable context-specific contribution and a promising theoretical model. However, the strength and generalizability of the conclusions depend on complete statistical reporting, construct validity, sample characteristics, and replication in actual marketplace settings. AI disclosure should not be treated as inherently harmful or beneficial. Its consequences depend on content accuracy, specificity, human involvement, accountability, product uncertainty, and consumer expectations.

For marketplace platforms, the most defensible strategy is transparent AI assistance supported by product-specific information, substantive human verification, seller accountability, and consumer protection. AI may simplify listing creation, but credible information and trust remain essential to successful second-hand transactions.

References

[1] J. Wang, W. Ru, and G. Ye, “Easy listing, hard selling? How AI-source disclosure in second-hand product descriptions shapes purchase intention,” Journal of Marketing Management, 2026. DOI as supplied by the user: 10.1080/0267257X.2026.2760826.

[2] T. Lin and Y. Zhang, “Visible sources and invisible risks: exploring the impact of AI disclosure on perceived credibility of AI-generated content,” Journal of Science Communication, vol. 25, no. 1, A09, 2026, doi: 10.22323/358020260107085703.

[3] A. Kirkby, C. Baumgarth, and J. Henseler, “To disclose or not disclose, is no longer the question – effect of AI-disclosed brand voice on brand authenticity and attitude,” Journal of Product & Brand Management, 2023. DOI: 10.1108/JPBM-02-2022-3864.

Note: Reference [1] should be checked against the publisher’s official record before submission. A secondary indexing page accessed for this review displayed a conflicting DOI, so the DOI provided in the original article details supplied by the user has been retained pending publisher verification.

Research integrity and reporting note

This document is a critical evaluation of an existing published study, not a new empirical investigation. No primary data were collected for this manuscript. Numerical results, sample sizes, or statistical coefficients have not been fabricated. Before submission, the original article should be consulted to verify all experimental details and complete references. Any use of AI assistance in preparing a submission should be disclosed according to the target journal’s policy.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Critical Evaluation of Complex Organizational Rituals: Employee Engagement, Behavioural Outcomes and Theoretical Limitations

 

Critical Evaluation of Complex Organizational Rituals: Employee Engagement, Behavioural Outcomes and Theoretical Limitations

A Critical Research Paper for Scopus-Oriented Academic Publication



Prepared by: Dr. Mamta Vyas
Independent Researcher – Management and Economics

 

Original Research Article Details

Particulars

Details

Original journal

Journal of Management

Original article

Is Everyone Having a Good Time? The Effects of Complex Organizational Rituals on Employee Engagement and Behavior

Original authors

Junhyok Yim, Trevor A. Foulk, Anthony C. Klotz and Pauline Schilpzand

Volume

52

Issue

8

Pages

3249–3286

Publication year

2026 (first published online, August 15, 2025)

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1177/01492063251355251

Research discipline

Organizational Behaviour, Human Resource Management and Management Research

Abstract

Background: Organizational rituals are traditionally considered instruments for strengthening employee relationships, organizational identification and workplace engagement. However, complex organizational rituals, including annual celebrations, team-building retreats and corporate gatherings, may also generate exclusion, emotional discomfort, attendance pressure and dissatisfaction. Yim et al. investigate this duality through Interaction Ritual Theory (IRT).

Objective: This paper critically evaluates the theoretical foundations, research design, measurement procedures, empirical findings and managerial implications of the original study. It examines whether the authors establish a sufficiently convincing relationship between ritual experiences, employee engagement and subsequent workplace behaviour.

Methodology: The study employs a critical literature-based research approach, examining the original article, its theoretical propositions, four-stage empirical investigation, measurement framework, statistical findings and relevant organizational behaviour literature. Particular attention is given to construct validity, sample composition, causal inference, cultural transferability and practical applicability.

Results: The original research provides evidence that positive ritual experiences enhance employee engagement and that negative experiences weaken the beneficial relationship. Its empirical findings are particularly interesting because negative experiences did not independently produce statistically significant reductions in engagement in either of the two principal model-testing studies. Instead, their influence emerged primarily through interaction with positive experiences. The research also identifies indirect relationships between engagement and helping, loyal boosterism and job-search behaviour.

Conclusion: Although the study makes an important theoretical and methodological contribution, questions remain concerning the measurement of complex rituals, the generalizability of its samples, the interpretation of behavioural outcomes and the distinction between association and causation. This paper proposes a more comprehensive framework incorporating organizational justice, social exchange, employee autonomy, cultural differences and organizational cost-effectiveness.

Keywords: Organizational Rituals, Employee Engagement, Interaction Ritual Theory, Organizational Behaviour, Employee Retention, Human Resource Management.

 

1. Introduction

1.1 Background of the Study

Organizations have traditionally used workplace rituals to establish a shared organizational identity, encourage cooperation and develop relationships among employees. Annual celebrations, award ceremonies, employee recognition programmes, onboarding activities, team-building exercises and corporate retreats are commonly used to strengthen the relationship between employees and their organizations.

From a managerial perspective, such activities are frequently treated as investments in organizational culture. Management expects employees to develop stronger interpersonal relationships, experience organizational belongingness and demonstrate greater commitment following participation.

However, an important question remains insufficiently examined: Does participation in an organizational ritual necessarily create a positive experience for every employee?

A corporate celebration may generate happiness for one employee while producing discomfort for another. An annual award ceremony may motivate recognized employees while making unrecognized employees feel undervalued. Similarly, an organization may arrange an expensive team-building retreat, but employees may interpret compulsory attendance as an interference with their personal lives.

Consequently, organizational rituals cannot be evaluated exclusively through their intended objectives. Their actual effectiveness must also be assessed through employees' experiences and subsequent behaviour.

Yim, Foulk, Klotz and Schilpzand (2025) address this issue in their research article, Is Everyone Having a Good Time? The Effects of Complex Organizational Rituals on Employee Engagement and Behavior. Their investigation challenges the assumption that organizational rituals are uniformly beneficial and introduces a more balanced understanding of positive and negative ritual experiences [1].

The study is particularly relevant to contemporary organizations because employee engagement has become an important concern in the context of workplace flexibility, changing employee expectations, employee retention and organizational culture.

1.2 Statement of the Research Problem

The central problem addressed in this critical research paper is the gap between the intended purpose of organizational rituals and the actual experiences of employees participating in them.

Organizations frequently invest financial and managerial resources in activities intended to improve employee morale. However, the effectiveness of these activities is often assessed through participation rates, event expenditure or management perceptions rather than through systematic evaluation of employee experiences.

This creates several important research questions:

1.      Can organizational rituals generate negative experiences despite being designed to improve employee engagement?

2.      Are positive experiences sufficient to generate long-term employee commitment?

3.      Can negative experiences neutralize the benefits of otherwise successful organizational events?

4.      Does employee engagement genuinely explain the relationship between ritual experiences and workplace behaviour?

5.      Can findings obtained from American and German employees be applied to organizations operating in other cultural and institutional environments?

The original research addresses several of these questions. Nevertheless, its theoretical and methodological approach requires further critical examination.

1.3 Research Objectives

The present critical investigation has the following objectives:

1.      To examine the theoretical foundations of complex organizational rituals using Interaction Ritual Theory.

2.      To critically evaluate the research design and empirical methodology adopted by Yim et al.

3.      To examine the relationship between positive and negative ritual experiences and employee engagement.

4.      To assess the statistical evidence supporting the proposed behavioural outcomes.

5.      To identify conceptual, methodological and contextual limitations.

6.      To examine the relevance of the findings for contemporary human resource management.

7.      To propose an expanded research framework for future organizational ritual studies.

1.4 Research Questions

RQ1: To what extent does the original study establish the relationship between complex organizational rituals and employee engagement?

RQ2: Do negative ritual experiences independently reduce engagement, or do they primarily weaken the benefits of positive experiences?

RQ3: How convincingly does employee engagement explain subsequent employee behaviour?

RQ4: What methodological and contextual limitations affect the generalizability of the findings?

RQ5: How can organizations develop inclusive, voluntary and economically effective workplace rituals?

1.5 Research Propositions

The following propositions guide the critical evaluation:

·         P1: Positive organizational ritual experiences are positively associated with employee engagement.

·         P2: Negative ritual experiences weaken the positive relationship between ritual experiences and employee engagement.

·         P3: Employee engagement is an important explanatory mechanism linking ritual experiences with helping behaviour and loyal boosterism.

·         P4: Organizational justice and employee autonomy influence how employees interpret complex organizational rituals.

·         P5: The effectiveness of organizational rituals varies according to organizational culture, employee characteristics and institutional context.

The first three propositions are grounded in the original research. The fourth and fifth extend its framework and are proposed for future investigation.

 

2. Literature Review and Theoretical Foundations

2.1 Organizational Rituals: Evolution of the Concept

Organizational rituals are structured collective activities through which members of an organization communicate shared values, reinforce social relationships and establish organizational identity.

Trice and Beyer [2] explain the importance of rites and ceremonies in understanding organizational culture. Their work establishes that organizational rituals are not merely social activities but also mechanisms through which organizational meanings and values are communicated.

Collins [3] developed Interaction Ritual Chains Theory, explaining how collective interactions can generate emotional energy, group solidarity and shared symbolic meanings.

Islam and Zyphur [4] subsequently examined the relevance of rituals within organizational environments, demonstrating the importance of understanding how rituals influence organizational relationships and behaviour.

However, an important distinction exists between simple and complex rituals.

Simple organizational rituals

Complex organizational rituals

Short duration

Extended duration

Limited interaction

Multiple interpersonal interactions

Relatively straightforward activities

Multiple activities and social expectations

Examples: morning meetings and team cheers

Examples: annual celebrations and corporate retreats

Limited organizational coordination

Greater planning and coordination

The distinction is important because longer and more socially demanding activities expose employees to a greater variety of experiences.

A successful morning team meeting may require limited participation, whereas a corporate retreat may involve travel, accommodation, formal presentations, social interaction and compulsory group activities.

Therefore, the possibility of negative experiences increases with the number of interactions and expectations involved.

2.2 Interaction Ritual Theory

The original study uses Interaction Ritual Theory as its principal theoretical foundation.

Collins [3] identifies four major conditions associated with successful interaction rituals:

1.      Physical co-presence or physical density.

2.      Boundaries separating participants from nonparticipants.

3.      Mutual focus of attention.

4.      Shared emotional mood.

These conditions create opportunities for collective emotional experiences, solidarity and emotional energy.

In organizational settings, these outcomes may be reflected in stronger interpersonal relationships, improved enthusiasm and increased willingness to contribute to organizational objectives.

However, the theory also recognizes that rituals may fail.

If employees experience exclusion, forced participation, inappropriate interactions or an absence of shared emotional commitment, the expected benefits may not materialize.

Critical assessment

The application of IRT to workplace activities is an important contribution of Yim et al. Nevertheless, the theory primarily explains the social and emotional dynamics of collective interaction.

It does not independently explain all organizational factors that determine whether employees consider a ritual fair, useful, voluntary or economically justified.

For example, an employee may enjoy the social atmosphere of a corporate celebration but still object to compulsory participation outside normal working hours.

Such an experience involves not only emotional energy but also employee autonomy, work-life balance and organizational justice.

Thus, IRT provides a strong starting point but should not be treated as a complete explanation of organizational ritual effectiveness.

2.3 Social Exchange Theory

Blau's Social Exchange Theory [5] suggests that relationships develop through reciprocal exchanges of benefits and obligations.

Organizations provide compensation, recognition, support and development opportunities, while employees contribute time, effort, commitment and organizational knowledge.

From this perspective, workplace rituals may be interpreted as organizational investments in employee relationships.

However, the perceived value of these investments depends on employee interpretation.

For example:

·         A voluntary employee appreciation event may communicate organizational recognition.

·         A compulsory weekend celebration may be interpreted as an additional work obligation.

·         An expensive corporate party may create dissatisfaction if employees simultaneously experience inadequate compensation or limited career opportunities.

This suggests that the benefits of organizational rituals cannot be understood independently of the broader employment relationship.

Critical contribution: Future research should examine whether employees interpret rituals as genuine organizational support or as symbolic substitutes for more substantive employment benefits.

2.4 Organizational Justice Theory

Organizational justice is particularly relevant when examining employee reactions to corporate ceremonies and recognition events.

Greenberg's work on organizational justice [6] provides a foundation for understanding employee perceptions of fairness.

Three dimensions are especially relevant:

·         Distributive justice: Whether recognition, rewards and benefits are distributed fairly.

·         Procedural justice: Whether the processes used to organize events and allocate recognition are fair.

·         Interactional justice: Whether employees are treated with dignity and respect.

For example, an award ceremony may generate positive experiences for selected employees but negative experiences among employees who believe that the recognition process is biased.

Similarly, excluding certain departments or employment categories from organizational celebrations may create feelings of organizational inequality.

The original research identifies exclusion as a negative experience during its inductive investigation. However, exclusion did not remain part of the final higher-order negative-experience construct used in the principal model.

This decision is methodologically understandable from a factor-structure perspective, but it raises an important theoretical question: Can exclusion be considered a separate organizational justice issue rather than simply another manifestation of negative ritual experience?

This is a particularly valuable direction for further research.

2.5 Employee Engagement Theory

Kahn [7] conceptualized personal engagement as the extent to which individuals express themselves physically, cognitively and emotionally through their work roles.

Rich, LePine and Crawford [8] subsequently developed a measure of job engagement that examines the investment of physical, emotional and cognitive resources.

Employee engagement is important because employees who are psychologically invested in their work are more likely to demonstrate initiative, commitment and constructive workplace behaviour.

Yim et al. use employee engagement as the principal mechanism connecting organizational ritual experiences with subsequent employee behaviour.

However, engagement should not automatically be interpreted as organizational loyalty.

An employee may demonstrate high professional engagement while remaining dissatisfied with organizational policies, compensation or leadership.

Therefore, engagement, commitment, satisfaction and organizational identification must be treated as related but distinct constructs.

2.6 Research Gap Identified

The literature indicates several areas requiring further investigation.

Research dimension

Existing research emphasis

Identified gap

Ritual experiences

Positive social outcomes

Detailed examination of negative experiences

Employee engagement

Psychological engagement

Long-term engagement sustainability

Organizational behaviour

Helping and loyalty

Actual performance and retention

Organizational justice

Fairness in employment relationships

Fairness within ritual participation

Employee autonomy

Participation in organizational activities

Voluntary versus compulsory participation

Cultural context

Limited national comparisons

Broader cross-cultural validation

Financial implications

Employee-related outcomes

Cost-effectiveness of organizational rituals

The central research gap is therefore not simply whether organizational rituals produce positive or negative outcomes. It is the absence of a sufficiently integrated framework explaining how organizational design, employee autonomy, fairness, cultural expectations and resource allocation jointly determine ritual effectiveness.

 

3. Original Research Study: Design and Empirical Architecture

3.1 Overview of the Original Investigation

An important correction to the simplified description of the original research is necessary.

The authors conducted a multi-stage investigation consisting of a pilot study, Study 1, Study 2a, Study 2b, Study 3 and Study 4.

The investigation included exploratory research, scale development, confirmatory factor analysis and two principal tests of the proposed theoretical model.

The research was conducted across the United Kingdom, the United States and Germany.

Table 1. Structure of the Original Research

Research stage

Sample

Country

Main purpose

Pilot study

200

UK

Identification of common complex rituals

Study 1

37

USA

Inductive identification of positive and negative experiences

Study 2a

441 valid responses

UK

Scale development and content validation

Study 2b

284 valid responses

USA

Examination of factor structure

Study 3

90

USA

Full theoretical model using workplace holiday parties

Study 4

497

Germany

Replication across multiple ritual types

<text>Source: Compiled from the original article and its accepted manuscript [1].</text>

The distinction between the exploratory and model-testing stages is important. The original paper is methodologically more extensive than a simple two-survey investigation.

3.2 Pilot Study

The pilot study surveyed 200 working adults in the United Kingdom through Prolific.

Participants reported 425 workplace rituals.

Six major categories were identified:

1.      Holiday parties: 25%.

2.      Team-building retreats: 23%.

3.      Annual meetings: 20%.

4.      Award ceremonies: 9%.

5.      Onboarding or leaving events: 7%.

6.      Company-specific celebrations: 6%.

The study established workplace celebrations and similar activities as suitable contexts for examining complex organizational rituals.

Critical observation: The pilot study provides useful exploratory evidence. However, the prevalence of reported ritual categories should not automatically be interpreted as their prevalence across the entire global working population. The sampling platform, geographical coverage and eligibility criteria influence the composition of the reported experiences.

3.3 Study 1: Identification of Employee Experiences

Study 1 included 37 participants from professional MBA programmes at a large university in the Western United States.

The researchers collected open-ended descriptions of positive and negative experiences during workplace celebrations.

Two researchers independently participated in the coding process and developed categories through an inductive approach.

The investigation identified six positive and seven negative experiences.

Table 2. Positive and Negative Organizational Ritual Experiences

Positive experiences

Frequency

Negative experiences

Frequency

Strengthen social fabric

41

Require personal sacrifices

36

Perquisites

40

Exclusion

20

Energetic environment

23

Hinder organizational functioning

16

Positive atmosphere

12

Underappreciation

13

Positive leadership

3

Encourage inauthenticity

13

Facilitate work

1

Attendance pressure

5

—

—

Facilitate unprofessionalism

2

Total

120

Total

105

Source: Original Study 1 qualitative coding results [1].

The findings demonstrate that employees can experience the same organizational event in substantially different ways.

Critical interpretation

The identification of personal sacrifices, exclusion and underappreciation is particularly important.

These experiences indicate that workplace rituals may reproduce existing organizational inequalities rather than automatically strengthen collective solidarity.

However, the sample of 37 participants limits the diversity of experiences that could be identified.

The researchers' coding process provides an initial conceptual foundation, but future research should use broader employee groups, multiple organizational settings and systematic intercoder agreement reporting to strengthen the reliability of the qualitative categories.

3.4 Study 2: Scale Development and Validation

The authors developed measurement scales for positive and negative ritual experiences.

Study 2a involved 441 valid responses from working adults in the United Kingdom.

Study 2b involved 284 participants from the United States.

The researchers initially examined four positive and five negative experiences.

However, exclusion did not load sufficiently onto the higher-order negative-experience construct and was removed from the final factor structure.

The final model therefore contained:

Positive experience dimensions

·         Strengthening social fabric.

·         Perquisites.

·         Energetic environment.

·         Positive atmosphere.

Negative experience dimensions

·         Requiring personal sacrifices.

·         Hindering organizational functioning.

·         Underappreciation.

·         Encouraging inauthenticity.

The confirmatory factor analysis in Study 2b reported the following model-fit indicators:

Indicator

Reported value

Chi-square

2084.22

Degrees of freedom

1071

CFI

0.92

RMSEA

0.06

SRMR

0.06

Critical interpretation

The scale-development procedure is one of the strongest elements of the original investigation.

Nevertheless, removing exclusion from the higher-order negative construct creates a potential conceptual limitation.

Exclusion may not be statistically similar to other negative experiences, but it remains an important organizational phenomenon.

A future measurement framework should consider exclusion as an independent dimension rather than assuming that its statistical separation makes it theoretically unimportant.

 

4. Research Methodology of the Present Critical Study

4.1 Research Design

The present paper adopts a critical, qualitative and analytical research design.

It evaluates an existing peer-reviewed research article rather than conducting a new primary employee survey.

The research approach consists of:

1.      Examination of the original research article.

2.      Critical evaluation of its theoretical foundations.

3.      Reconstruction of its empirical research architecture.

4.      Assessment of reported statistical results.

5.      Evaluation of measurement and sampling procedures.

6.      Comparison with established organizational behaviour theories.

7.      Development of an extended conceptual framework.

4.2 Sources of Information

The investigation uses the original Journal of Management article, its accessible accepted manuscript and relevant theoretical publications.

The evidence is differentiated into three categories:

·         Original evidence: Findings, sample sizes, measurements and statistical results reported by Yim et al.

·         Critical interpretation: Evaluation of the original findings by the present researcher.

·         Proposed extension: New theoretical relationships and research propositions suggested for future empirical investigation.

4.3 Analytical Techniques

The critical assessment uses:

·         Theoretical comparison.

·         Construct-validity assessment.

·         Descriptive examination of reported sample characteristics.

·         Evaluation of reported regression and structural equation modelling results.

·         Assessment of statistical significance and confidence intervals.

·         Comparative analysis of the two principal model-testing studies.

·         Identification of alternative explanations and boundary conditions.

No new regression, ANOVA, chi-square, SEM or reliability coefficients are claimed because the present investigation does not contain an independently collected respondent-level dataset.

4.4 Ethical Considerations

The paper uses published research findings and established academic literature.

It does not claim ownership of the original authors' empirical observations. Statistical findings are attributed to their original source, and proposed hypotheses are distinguished from established empirical conclusions.

 

5. Results and Critical Empirical Analysis

5.1 Study 3: Workplace Holiday Parties

Study 3 involved 90 professional MBA students from two universities in the United States.

The research adopted a three-time-point design:

·         Time 1: Positive and negative experiences following the workplace holiday party.

·         Time 2: Employee engagement, one week later.

·         Time 3: Helping, loyal boosterism and job-search behaviour, one week after Time 2.

The researchers used established engagement and behavioural measurement instruments.

The statistical model was estimated using full-information maximum likelihood and latent moderated structural equation modelling.

Table 3. Principal Findings of Study 3

Relationship

Coefficient (B)

p-value

Result

Positive experiences → Engagement

0.60

0.020

Significant

Negative experiences → Engagement

-0.38

0.202

Not significant

Positive × Negative experiences → Engagement

-0.63

0.044

Significant negative interaction

Engagement → Helping

0.31

Less than 0.001

Significant

Engagement → Loyal boosterism

0.60

Less than 0.001

Significant

Engagement → Job search behaviour

-0.33

0.007

Significant

Source: Original Study 3 results [1].

The interaction effect is particularly important.

The positive relationship between positive ritual experiences and engagement was stronger when negative experiences were low.

The reported simple slopes were:

·         Lower negative experiences: 0.95, p = 0.005.

·         Higher negative experiences: 0.26, p = 0.339.

This suggests that positive experiences do not generate the same engagement benefits when employees simultaneously experience substantial negative aspects of the event.

Critical Interpretation

The results challenge a simplistic management assumption that organizing enjoyable events is sufficient to improve employee engagement.

However, the absence of a statistically significant independent relationship between negative experiences and engagement is equally important.

The original findings do not establish that negative experiences independently reduce engagement in Study 3.

Instead, they demonstrate that negative experiences weaken the positive relationship between favourable experiences and engagement.

This distinction should be maintained when interpreting the research.

Methodological Concern

The authors acknowledge that the sample size of Study 3 was insufficient for obtaining reliable confirmatory factor analysis results for the complete measurement model.

The number of parameters exceeded the available sample size, preventing the intended model from converging.

The authors subsequently addressed this issue through the larger Study 4.

This acknowledgement strengthens research transparency, but it also means that the Study 3 findings should not be interpreted independently of the limitations of its measurement-model estimation.

5.2 Study 4: Multiple Organizational Rituals

Study 4 examined employees in Germany who had recently participated in one of six types of complex organizational rituals.

The final sample consisted of 497 participants.

The distribution of ritual participation was as follows.

Table 4. Distribution of Ritual Types in Study 4

Type of ritual

Percentage

Holiday parties

42%

Team-building retreats

30%

Onboarding or leaving events

14%

Annual meetings

6%

Company-specific celebrations

5%

Award ceremonies

2%

Other or rounding difference

1%

Source: Original Study 4 sample composition [1]. The final category percentages are rounded.

Study 4 used a larger sample and included additional individual and organizational control variables.

These included:

·         Age and gender.

·         Race.

·         Organizational tenure.

·         Extraversion.

·         Perceived organizational support.

·         Frequency of rituals.

·         Scope of rituals.

·         Number of attendees.

The confirmatory factor analysis reported:

Model-fit indicator

Reported value

Chi-square

6598.18

Degrees of freedom

3628

CFI

0.90

RMSEA

0.04

SRMR

0.07

The model demonstrated an acceptable overall fit according to the authors' assessment.

Table 5. Principal Findings of Study 4

Relationship

Coefficient (B)

p-value

Result

Positive experiences → Engagement

0.30

Less than 0.001

Significant

Negative experiences → Engagement

-0.06

0.572

Not significant

Positive × Negative experiences → Engagement

-0.18

0.001

Significant negative interaction

Engagement → Helping

0.28

Less than 0.001

Significant

Engagement → Loyal boosterism

0.26

Less than 0.001

Significant

Engagement → Job search behaviour

-0.23

0.008

Significant

Source: Original Study 4 results [1].

Critical Interpretation

Study 4 provides important support for the theoretical model.

Positive ritual experiences were associated with higher engagement, while negative experiences weakened the positive relationship.

The simple slopes were:

·         Lower negative experiences: 0.41, p less than 0.001.

·         Higher negative experiences: 0.19, p = 0.018.

Unlike Study 3, the relationship remained statistically significant even when negative experiences were relatively high, although its strength was reduced.

The findings suggest that positive experiences can retain some benefits despite negative aspects of an organizational event.

However, negative experiences independently predicted engagement at a coefficient of -0.06, which was not statistically significant.

This result is important because it prevents an overly broad conclusion that negative ritual experiences necessarily reduce engagement.

 

6. Comparative Assessment of Study 3 and Study 4

Table 6. Comparative Empirical Assessment

Research dimension

Study 3

Study 4

Country

USA

Germany

Sample

90

497

Ritual coverage

Holiday parties

Six ritual categories

Design

Three time points

Two time points

Positive experience effect

Significant

Significant

Independent negative experience effect

Not significant

Not significant

Interaction effect

Significant

Significant

Engagement and helping

Significant

Significant

Engagement and loyal boosterism

Significant

Significant

Engagement and job search

Significant negative

Significant negative

Overall assessment

The replication across two different national settings strengthens confidence in the central interaction finding.

Nevertheless, the studies do not establish universal cultural applicability.

Study 3 focuses on American MBA students, while Study 4 uses English-speaking working adults in Germany recruited through Prolific.

Neither study constitutes a representative probability sample of the entire national workforce.

Furthermore, the two studies differ in ritual coverage and research design. Therefore, their results should be considered complementary evidence rather than perfectly equivalent replications.

 

7. Critical Evaluation of the Original Research

7.1 Theoretical Contribution: Strengths

The most significant contribution of the research is its movement beyond the assumption that organizational rituals are automatically beneficial.

The original authors demonstrate that employees may experience both favourable and unfavourable aspects within the same event.

The interaction between positive and negative experiences is particularly valuable because it explains why an organizational ritual can generate mixed outcomes.

This provides a more realistic understanding of employee behaviour than approaches that classify events as simply successful or unsuccessful.

7.2 Conceptual Limitation: Defining Complexity

The authors distinguish complex rituals through their duration, social interaction and requirements for focused attention.

However, complexity may also depend on:

·         The number of activities involved.

·         The diversity of participants.

·         Organizational hierarchy.

·         Emotional expectations.

·         Employee participation requirements.

·         Financial and time commitments.

·         The extent of formal organizational control.

A three-hour departmental celebration and a three-day international corporate retreat may both qualify as complex rituals, but their organizational demands are substantially different.

Future research should therefore develop a multidimensional complexity index.

7.3 Theoretical Limitation: Emotional Energy and Employee Engagement

The authors conceptualize employee engagement as an organizationally situated manifestation of emotional energy.

This is theoretically interesting, but the two concepts should not automatically be treated as identical.

Emotional energy may be temporary and situation-dependent, whereas employee engagement is generally conceptualized as a broader work-related psychological state.

The original research measures engagement through an established instrument rather than directly measuring all the components of emotional energy proposed by IRT.

Consequently, the theoretical mechanism is supported indirectly rather than through a complete measurement of the original theory's central construct.

Critical question: If employee engagement is a manifestation of emotional energy, how much of the observed relationship reflects actual ritual-generated emotional energy and how much reflects employees' existing attitudes towards their jobs?

This remains an important question for future research.

7.4 Measurement Limitation: Exclusion

One of the most interesting methodological decisions concerns the exclusion dimension.

The original qualitative investigation identified exclusion as a negative ritual experience. However, it was removed from the higher-order negative-experience factor during the subsequent scale-validation process.

Statistical separation may be justified when a construct does not adequately load onto a common factor.

Nevertheless, exclusion has a distinct theoretical significance.

For example, exclusion from an annual celebration may reflect:

·         Employment-status differences.

·         Departmental discrimination.

·         Hierarchical inequality.

·         Inadequate communication.

·         Unfair access to organizational benefits.

Such experiences may influence organizational identification and trust even when they do not correlate strongly with personal sacrifices or feelings of inauthenticity.

The critical recommendation is to measure exclusion independently in future organizational ritual research.

7.5 Sampling Limitations

The study includes multiple countries and different research stages, which is a strength.

However, several limitations remain.

First, Study 1 relies on a small group of professional MBA students.

Second, Study 3 includes only 90 participants.

Third, Study 4 includes 497 English-speaking employees recruited through an online research platform rather than a representative national workforce survey.

Fourth, the distribution of participants across occupations and organizational levels is not sufficiently broad to establish whether the findings apply equally to frontline workers, manufacturing employees, senior executives, public-sector employees and academic professionals.

The original paper includes several occupational examples, but occupational diversity alone does not establish representativeness.

7.6 Causal Inference

The research adopts time-separated data collection, which is stronger than collecting all variables in a single questionnaire.

Study 3 measures ritual experiences after the event, engagement one week later and behavioural outcomes subsequently.

Study 4 measures ritual experiences and engagement at Time 1 and behavioural outcomes one week later.

This temporal separation helps establish an ordered sequence of measurement.

However, time separation alone does not establish causality.

Employees who were already highly engaged may interpret organizational events more positively.

Employees experiencing job dissatisfaction may interpret the same event negatively.

Similarly, management quality, compensation, supervisor support and workplace climate may influence both ritual experiences and employee engagement.

The possibility of reverse causality and omitted-variable bias therefore remains.

Future research should use baseline engagement measurements, pre- and post-event comparisons and, where practical, controlled organizational interventions.

7.7 Behavioural Measurement

The original research examines three behavioural outcomes:

1.      Helping.

2.      Loyal boosterism.

3.      Job search behaviour.

These outcomes are relevant to organizational functioning.

However, the study uses survey-based measures of reported behaviour rather than independently verified organizational performance or retention records.

For example, reporting that an employee has helped colleagues does not necessarily establish an independently observed increase in helping behaviour.

Similarly, job-search behaviour is not equivalent to actual resignation or employee turnover.

This distinction is essential.

A future investigation should incorporate supervisor ratings, HR records, actual employee retention and independently recorded performance indicators.

7.8 Cultural Generalizability

The inclusion of the United States and Germany is valuable, but it should not be interpreted as comprehensive cross-cultural validation.

The study does not establish whether the same relationships operate in India, Japan, China, Brazil or Middle Eastern organizations.

Cultural values, employment relationships, organizational hierarchy and expectations concerning collective participation may differ considerably.

For instance, in some organizations, collective celebrations may be interpreted as an important expression of belongingness. In others, employees may place greater emphasis on personal time and voluntary participation.

The same ritual may therefore generate different experiences across organizational and cultural environments.

Future research should examine cultural moderation rather than assuming that the results automatically transfer across countries.

7.9 Statistical Interpretation

The study's statistical findings should be interpreted carefully.

The most important finding is the significant negative interaction between positive and negative experiences.

However, the independent negative-experience coefficients were statistically insignificant in both principal model-testing studies.

This indicates that the authors' central argument is more accurately expressed as:

Negative experiences weaken the engagement benefits associated with positive experiences rather than independently and consistently reducing employee engagement.

This is a more precise interpretation than claiming that negative rituals directly reduce engagement in every situation.

The distinction improves the validity of the critical assessment.

 

8. Extended Conceptual Framework Proposed by the Present Researcher

The original research establishes an important relationship between ritual experiences, employee engagement and behavioural outcomes.

However, the present analysis argues that organizational rituals should be examined through a broader framework.

Four additional dimensions are proposed:

1.      Employee autonomy.

2.      Organizational justice.

3.      Cultural and institutional context.

4.      Economic and organizational effectiveness.

8.1 Proposed Research Model

Figure 1. Extended Framework of Complex Organizational Ritual Effectiveness

Organizational ritual characteristics:

·         Duration.

·         Participation requirements.

·         Social interaction.

·         Financial expenditure.

·         Organizational purpose.

These influence:

Positive experiences and negative experiences.

Additional contextual influences:

·         Employee autonomy.

·         Organizational justice.

·         Leadership support.

·         Cultural expectations.

These factors jointly influence employee engagement and related psychological outcomes.

Employee engagement subsequently influences:

·         Helping behaviour.

·         Organizational advocacy.

·         Job-search behaviour.

·         Actual retention.

·         Work performance.

Organizational effectiveness should finally be assessed against the financial and managerial resources invested in the ritual.

8.2 Proposed Mathematical Model

The following is a proposed conceptual model for future empirical testing. It is not a regression estimated from the original article's data.

Let employee engagement be represented by:

Engagement = B0 + B1(Positive Ritual Experiences) + B2(Negative Ritual Experiences) + B3(Positive Experiences × Negative Experiences) + B4(Employee Autonomy) + B5(Organizational Justice) + B6(Leadership Support) + B7(Cultural Context) + Error Term.

The expected relationships are:

·         B1: Positive.

·         B2: To be empirically determined.

·         B3: Negative.

·         B4: Positive.

·         B5: Positive.

·         B6: Positive.

·         B7: Context-dependent.

The model provides a broader basis for examining organizational ritual effectiveness.

8.3 Additional Research Propositions

P6: Voluntary participation produces more favourable employee experiences than compulsory participation, controlling for other ritual characteristics.

P7: Perceived organizational justice positively influences employee responses to recognition-based rituals.

P8: Employee autonomy moderates the relationship between negative ritual experiences and engagement.

P9: The relationship between ritual experiences and engagement differs across organizational cultures and occupational groups.

P10: The effectiveness of complex rituals depends on the relationship between measurable employee outcomes and organizational resource expenditure.

These propositions require independent empirical testing.

 

9. Managerial Implications

9.1 Reconsidering Compulsory Participation

Organizations should reconsider the assumption that high participation rates necessarily indicate successful rituals.

Employees may attend because of managerial expectations rather than genuine interest.

Where possible, participation should be voluntary, particularly for activities conducted outside normal working hours.

9.2 Recognition Must Be Fair

Award ceremonies should follow transparent and credible recognition criteria.

Organizations should avoid designing events in ways that create unnecessary feelings of exclusion or underappreciation.

Recognition programmes should communicate appreciation across different levels and categories of employment.

9.3 Employee Feedback Should Be Systematic

Organizations should collect feedback after major events.

The evaluation should include:

·         Social interaction.

·         Perceived inclusion.

·         Employee satisfaction.

·         Time and personal inconvenience.

·         Organizational relevance.

·         Perceived fairness.

·         Suggestions for improvement.

Feedback should be confidential wherever possible to encourage honest responses.

9.4 Rituals Should Have Clear Organizational Objectives

A corporate celebration should not be treated as an automatic employee engagement intervention.

Organizations should distinguish between:

·         Social celebrations.

·         Employee recognition.

·         Professional development.

·         Team-building.

·         Organizational communication.

Each activity should have an identifiable purpose and an appropriate evaluation method.

9.5 Economic Evaluation

Organizations should examine the relationship between expenditure and measurable outcomes.

Table 7. Proposed Organizational Ritual Evaluation Framework

Evaluation dimension

Suggested indicator

Financial investment

Total event expenditure

Employee participation

Voluntary participation rate

Inclusion

Employee-reported inclusion

Engagement

Pre-event and post-event engagement

Recognition

Perceived fairness of recognition

Productivity

Relevant work-performance indicators

Retention

Subsequent employee turnover

Organizational value

Benefits relative to total expenditure

The framework is proposed for future application; it does not represent financial results established by the original study.

 

10. Future Research Directions

10.1 Longitudinal Research

Future researchers should examine employee experiences before an organizational ritual, immediately after participation and at subsequent intervals.

Measurements at one month, three months and six months could establish whether the effects persist.

10.2 Comparative Industry Research

Future investigations should compare:

·         Manufacturing organizations.

·         Information technology companies.

·         Banking and financial institutions.

·         Educational institutions.

·         Healthcare organizations.

·         Public-sector organizations.

The meaning and effectiveness of rituals may vary considerably across these environments.

10.3 Indian Organizational Context

An important extension would be to examine organizational rituals in Indian organizations.

Indian workplaces provide a particularly interesting research environment because organizational celebrations may involve professional recognition, festivals, collective participation, hierarchical relationships and social obligations.

Possible research settings include:

·         Annual corporate functions.

·         Diwali celebrations.

·         Employee recognition ceremonies.

·         Foundation Day events.

·         Corporate retreats.

·         Faculty development and institutional gatherings.

·         New employee induction programmes.

A comparative study could examine whether employees experience these activities as organizational support, cultural participation or additional workplace obligations.

Such an investigation should avoid assuming that Indian employees form a culturally uniform group.

10.4 Employee Demographic Differences

Future studies should examine whether ritual experiences vary according to:

·         Age.

·         Gender.

·         Organizational tenure.

·         Employment status.

·         Occupational category.

·         Seniority.

·         Family responsibilities.

·         Work arrangements.

These factors may influence the willingness and ability of employees to participate in organizational events.

10.5 Experimental Research

Researchers could conduct field experiments comparing different ritual designs.

For example, two comparable departments could be offered different participation formats:

·         Department A: Compulsory attendance.

·         Department B: Voluntary attendance.

Employee feedback, engagement and subsequent behaviour could then be compared, subject to ethical safeguards and appropriate organizational consent.

This approach would provide stronger evidence about the influence of employee autonomy.

10.6 Actual Employee Retention

Future research should distinguish job-search intentions, reported job-search activity and actual employee turnover.

This distinction is important because an employee may explore external employment opportunities without resigning.

HR records and longitudinal employee tracking would provide stronger evidence of actual retention outcomes.

 

11. Limitations of the Present Critical Study

The present investigation has several limitations.

First, it critically evaluates one principal research article rather than conducting a systematic review of all available organizational ritual research.

Second, it relies on the original authors' reported findings and does not have access to the underlying respondent-level dataset.

Third, the proposed extended framework has not been empirically tested.

Fourth, the paper does not claim new primary data, original survey results or independent statistical validation.

Finally, the practical applicability of the proposed framework will require testing across different countries, industries and organizational environments.

These limitations should be acknowledged when interpreting the contribution of the present paper.

 

12. Conclusion

Yim, Foulk, Klotz and Schilpzand's research represents an important contribution to organizational behaviour and human resource management.

Its central contribution lies in demonstrating that complex organizational rituals should not be evaluated exclusively through their intended positive outcomes.

Employees may experience social connection, recognition, entertainment and organizational belongingness while simultaneously experiencing personal sacrifices, underappreciation, inconvenience and inauthenticity.

The empirical investigation provides evidence that positive experiences are associated with increased employee engagement and that negative experiences weaken this relationship.

The two principal model-testing studies also identify indirect relationships between engagement and helping, loyal boosterism and job-search behaviour.

However, the critical evaluation identifies several areas requiring further investigation.

The most important include the operationalization of ritual complexity, the conceptual relationship between emotional energy and employee engagement, the removal of exclusion from the higher-order negative construct, the limitations of the samples and the dependence on self-reported behavioural outcomes.

The distinction between employee engagement and actual organizational performance also requires greater attention.

The most important conclusion is that organizational rituals should be understood as organizational interventions rather than automatically beneficial social activities.

Their effectiveness depends not only on what management intends to communicate but also on how employees actually experience the event.

Organizations should therefore move from an event-centred approach to an employee-centred approach.

The success of a workplace ritual should not be determined by the amount of money spent, the number of employees attending or the entertainment provided. It should be evaluated through fairness, inclusion, employee autonomy, meaningful interaction and measurable organizational outcomes.

The fundamental contribution of this critical paper is the proposition that successful organizational rituals are not those in which everyone is required to participate, but those in which employees have meaningful reasons to participate.

This perspective provides a foundation for future research into employee engagement, organizational justice, workplace culture and sustainable human resource management.

 

References

[1] J. Yim, T. A. Foulk, A. C. Klotz, and P. Schilpzand, "Is everyone having a good time? The effects of complex organizational rituals on employee engagement and behavior," Journal of Management, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 3249–3286, Nov. 2026. First published online Aug. 15, 2025. doi: 10.1177/01492063251355251.

[2] H. M. Trice and J. M. Beyer, "Studying organizational cultures through rites and ceremonials," Academy of Management Review, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 653–669, 1984.

[3] R. Collins, Interaction Ritual Chains. Princeton, NJ, USA: Princeton University Press, 2004.

[4] G. Islam and M. J. Zyphur, "Rituals in organizations: A review and expansion of current theory," Group & Organization Management, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 114–139, 2009.

[5] P. M. Blau, Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York, NY, USA: John Wiley & Sons, 1964.

[6] J. Greenberg, "A taxonomy of organizational justice theories," Academy of Management Review, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 9–22, 1987.

[7] W. A. Kahn, "Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work," Academy of Management Journal, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 692–724, 1990.

[8] B. Rich, J. A. LePine, and E. Crawford, "Job engagement: Antecedents and effects on job performance," Academy of Management Journal, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 617–635, 2010.

[9] N. M. Ashkanasy and R. H. Humphrey, "Current emotion research in organizational behavior," Emotion Review, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 214–224, 2011.

[10] P. M. Podsakoff, S. B. MacKenzie, J. Y. Lee, and N. P. Podsakoff, "Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies," Journal of Applied Psychology, vol. 88, no. 5, pp. 879–903, 2003.

[11] J. A. Allen and S. G. Rogelberg, "Manager-led group meetings: A context for promoting employee engagement," Group & Organization Management, vol. 38, pp. 543–569, 2013.

[12] W. B. Schaufeli, A. B. Bakker, and M. Salanova, "The measurement of work engagement with a short questionnaire: A cross-national study," Educational and Psychological Measurement, vol. 66, no. 4, pp. 701–716, 2006.