Beyond Fertility: A Critical
Examination of the Religious Education Gap in India and the Quantity–Quality
Trade-off
A Critical Research Analysis of Fertility, Household Economics,
Educational Inequality and Public Policy

1. Title Page
Original research article details
|
Particulars |
Details |
|
Original journal name |
Population Research and Policy Review |
|
Original article title |
To What Extent Does the Fertility Rate Explain the Education Gap? |
|
Original authors |
Gitanjali Sen, Mitul Surana and Rakesh Basant |
|
Journal volume |
Volume 42 |
|
Issue |
3 |
|
Publication year |
2023 |
|
Publication date |
June 2023 |
|
Pages |
1–31 |
|
DOI |
|
|
Publisher |
Springer |
|
Original article status |
Published research article |
Source: Original article bibliographic record and ResearchGate publication
details. [1], [2].
Prepared by
Dr. Mamta Vyas
Independent Researcher
Management and Economics
India
.Proposed critical research paper
Title: Beyond Fertility: A Critical Examination of the
Religious Education Gap in India and the Quantity–Quality Trade-off
Research classification: Critical Review and Secondary Data
Analysis
Research orientation: Education Economics, Development
Economics, Population Studies, Social Inequality and Public Policy.
2. Abstract
Background: Educational inequality in India is influenced
by household income, fertility patterns, parental education, gender, social
circumstances and institutional access. Sen, Surana and Basant (2023)
investigate whether fertility differences explain the educational gap between
Muslim and Hindu populations through the quantity–quality trade-off.
Methods: This study critically evaluates the original
research using a structured review of its theoretical framework, decomposition
approach and reported findings. Secondary demographic evidence from India's
National Family Health Surveys (NFHS-4 and NFHS-5) is examined to assess
changes in fertility patterns. Descriptive comparisons, percentage differences
and critical methodological evaluation are employed.
Results: The original research reports that family size
accounts for approximately 10% of the years-of-schooling gap between Muslims
and high-caste Hindus, increasing to approximately 16% for secondary education
completion. However, subsequent NFHS-5 evidence indicates that fertility
differences have declined. Muslim total fertility declined from 2.62 in 2015–16
to 2.36 in 2019–21, while Hindu fertility declined from 2.13 to 1.94. These
findings suggest that fertility is relevant but insufficient to explain
educational inequality independently.
Conclusion: Fertility should be understood as one component
of a broader household and institutional framework. Educational expenditure,
women's empowerment, parental literacy, school accessibility, household poverty
and educational quality deserve greater attention. The paper recommends a
multidimensional approach to educational inequality rather than excessive
reliance on fertility-based explanations.
Keywords: Fertility Rate, Educational Inequality,
Quantity–Quality Trade-off, Religious Disparities, Household Economics, India.
3. Introduction
3.1 Background of the research
Education is one of the most important instruments of economic development,
social mobility and human capital formation. In developing economies such as
India, educational attainment is not determined exclusively by the availability
of schools or government expenditure.
Household characteristics influence whether children enter school, continue
their education and complete secondary or higher education.
Family size, household income, parental education, gender preferences,
occupational conditions and social institutions jointly influence educational
decisions.
An important economic explanation for this relationship is the Quantity–Quality
Trade-off Theory.
The theory suggests that households facing limited financial and time
resources may experience difficulties in maintaining the same level of
educational investment when the number of children increases.
The original research by Sen, Surana and Basant examines this relationship
in the context of educational differences between Muslim and Hindu populations
in India.
The authors report that family size explains approximately 10% of the
educational gap in years of schooling between Muslims and high-caste Hindus.
Its contribution increases to approximately 16% when secondary education
completion is examined. [1]
These findings create an important research question:
If fertility explains only a proportion of educational inequality,
what accounts for the remaining educational disadvantage?
This critical research paper investigates that question.
3.2 Statement of the research
problem
The central problem is the possibility of interpreting fertility differences
as a major explanation for educational inequality without sufficiently
considering the economic, institutional and social conditions that influence educational
outcomes.
A higher number of children may reduce the financial resources available per
child. However, the relationship is not universal.
For example:
·
A low-income family with two children may
struggle to finance secondary education.
·
A higher-income family with four children may
afford private schooling and additional educational support.
·
A family with educated parents may prioritise
education despite having several children.
·
A family living in a remote village may face
educational disadvantages even with a small number of children.
Therefore, fertility cannot be examined independently of household resources
and educational infrastructure.
3.3 Significance of the research
The study is significant for five reasons:
1. It
examines the limitations of fertility-centred explanations of educational
inequality.
2. It
evaluates the relevance of the quantity–quality theory in the Indian context.
3. It
distinguishes demographic differences from the economic mechanisms behind
educational outcomes.
4. It
examines whether changing fertility patterns require a reconsideration of
earlier conclusions.
5. It
develops policy recommendations for improving educational access and
attainment.
3.4 Research objectives
1. To
critically examine the theoretical foundation of the original article.
2. To
evaluate the reported contribution of fertility to educational inequality.
3. To
analyse Hindu–Muslim fertility differences using NFHS-4 and NFHS-5 evidence.
4. To
identify methodological and interpretative limitations in fertility-based
explanations.
5. To
examine the influence of household economics, gender and institutional access
on education.
6. To
recommend a multidimensional framework for reducing educational inequality in
India.
3.5 Research questions
·
RQ1: To what extent can fertility explain
differences in educational attainment?
·
RQ2: Does a declining fertility gap necessarily
translate into a declining educational gap?
·
RQ3: What other household and institutional
factors influence educational inequality?
·
RQ4: Is the quantity–quality trade-off equally
applicable across different income and social groups?
·
RQ5: What policy interventions can improve
educational attainment independently of fertility reduction?
3.6 Research hypotheses
|
Hypothesis |
Statement |
|
H1 |
Fertility differences are associated with differences in educational
attainment. |
|
H2 |
Household economic conditions influence the relationship between family
size and educational investment. |
|
H3 |
Parental education and school accessibility independently influence
children's educational outcomes. |
|
H4 |
Declining fertility differences do not necessarily eliminate educational
inequalities. |
|
H5 |
A multidimensional education policy is more appropriate than a
fertility-centred policy. |
These hypotheses are propositions for future empirical testing. The present
critical review does not claim to have statistically accepted or rejected them.
4. Literature Review
4.1 Quantity–Quality Theory
The foundation of the quantity–quality trade-off is associated with Becker
and Lewis (1973).
Their economic framework explains the interaction between the number of
children in a household and the resources invested in each child's development.
The basic economic argument is:
When household resources are constrained, an increase in the number of
children may reduce the resources available for each child.
However, the relationship depends on household income, preferences, parental
education and the cost of raising children.
The theory provides a useful foundation for examining educational
investment, but it should not be interpreted as a universal law. [3]
4.2 Family size and children's
education
Black, Devereux and Salvanes (2005) examine the relationship between family
size, birth order and children's education.
Their research demonstrates the importance of examining whether family size
itself affects educational attainment rather than simply observing correlations
between larger families and lower education.
This distinction is particularly relevant to the Indian context, where
family size may be associated with poverty, rural residence and parental
educational attainment. [4]
4.3 Fertility and household
economics
Rosenzweig and Zhang (2009) examine the relationship between population
policies, family size and human capital investment using evidence from Chinese
twins.
Their research illustrates the importance of addressing the problem of
endogeneity when estimating the effect of family size on child outcomes.
The critical implication is that families do not randomly acquire different
numbers of children. Fertility decisions may be related to household
characteristics that also influence education. [5]
4.4 Education and fertility are
interconnected
An important limitation of fertility-centred research is that the
relationship can operate in both directions.
Higher female education may influence:
·
Age at marriage.
·
Age at first childbirth.
·
Knowledge of reproductive health.
·
Employment opportunities.
·
Family planning decisions.
·
Desired family size.
Consequently, fertility may influence education, but education may also
influence fertility.
Diebolt, Mishra and Perrin (2021) examine the relationship between
education, fertility and gender empowerment, highlighting the importance of
understanding the interaction between these variables. [6]
4.5 Critical evaluation of the
literature
|
Researcher |
Major contribution |
Critical relevance |
|
Becker and Lewis (1973) |
Quantity–quality theory |
Provides theoretical foundation |
|
Black et al. (2005) |
Family size and educational outcomes |
Highlights identification issues |
|
Rosenzweig and Zhang (2009) |
Family size and human capital investment |
Demonstrates importance of causal identification |
|
Sen et al. (2023) |
Fertility and religious educational gaps in India |
Main article under examination |
|
Diebolt et al. (2021) |
Education, fertility and empowerment |
Highlights reverse causality and gender dimensions |
4.6 Identified research gaps
The literature review identifies the following gaps:
Gap 1: Fertility versus educational infrastructure
The relationship between family size and education needs to be examined
alongside school quality, distance, transport and availability of secondary
education.
Gap 2: Household expenditure
The number of children does not necessarily determine the amount spent on
education. Household income and educational priorities also matter.
Gap 3: Gender differences
Girls and boys may experience different educational opportunities within the
same household.
Gap 4: Changing demographic patterns
Fertility differences change over time. Earlier relationships should
therefore be reassessed using subsequent demographic surveys.
Gap 5: Educational progression
School enrolment, years of schooling, secondary completion and higher
education participation represent different outcomes. They should not be
treated as interchangeable measures of educational equality.
Gap 6: Policy effectiveness
The extent to which interventions in family planning, scholarships,
transport, school infrastructure and parental awareness improve educational
outcomes requires further investigation.
5. Critical Analysis of the Original
Research Article
5.1 Central argument of the original
article
The original research examines whether fertility differences contribute to
the educational gap between Muslim and Hindu populations in India.
Its central argument is based on the proposition that larger family size can
create financial and resource constraints, potentially reducing educational
investment per child.
The authors employ decomposition techniques to estimate the contribution of
family size to educational differences.
Their principal reported findings are:
|
Research finding |
Reported contribution |
|
Family size contribution to years-of-schooling gap between Muslims and
high-caste Hindus |
Approximately 10% |
|
Contribution to secondary education completion gap |
Approximately 16% |
|
Fertility difference between Muslim and Hindu women, NFHS-4 period |
Approximately 24% |
The findings are taken from the published abstract and bibliographic record.
[1], [2].
5.2 Strengths of the original
research
1. Originality
The article addresses an important but relatively underexamined question:
whether differences in fertility contribute to educational inequality between
religious groups.
It moves beyond conventional explanations based exclusively on income and
school availability.
2. Theoretical relevance
The application of quantity–quality theory to India's religious and
educational context provides a meaningful economic framework.
3. Empirical orientation
The authors use decomposition methods rather than relying exclusively on
descriptive comparisons.
4. Policy significance
The research connects demographic characteristics with educational policy,
family planning and public investment.
5. Recognition of multiple interventions
Importantly, the authors do not recommend fertility reduction as the only
solution. They also identify better schooling, safer transportation,
affordability and awareness as relevant policy measures.
5.3 Critical weaknesses and
limitations
The following are critical issues for further investigation, rather than
claims that the original authors necessarily ignored these matters in their
complete paper.
Weakness 1: Limited explanatory power of fertility
The reported 10% contribution indicates that approximately 90% of the
measured years-of-schooling gap remains outside the family-size component of
the decomposition.
This does not mean that the remaining 90% is caused by one particular
factor. It means that fertility differences alone cannot account for most of
the measured gap.
This raises an important question:
Why does the research place substantial attention on fertility when its
estimated contribution is comparatively limited?
A stronger analytical framework would examine the remaining educational
inequality through income, parental education, gender, school accessibility and
institutional quality.
Weakness 2: Association is not necessarily causation
A larger family may be associated with lower educational attainment.
However, this does not automatically establish that larger family size causes
lower educational attainment.
For example, low household income may simultaneously influence:
·
Fertility decisions.
·
Children's school enrolment.
·
Educational expenditure.
·
Continuation into secondary education.
Thus, poverty may be a common underlying factor.
The distinction between correlation, explained differences and causal
effects is essential for interpreting decomposition results.
Weakness 3: The problem of reverse causality
The relationship between education and fertility is potentially
bidirectional.
Women's education may reduce fertility through delayed marriage, employment
opportunities and greater access to reproductive health information.
Therefore, the research question should not be restricted to:
Does fertility explain educational inequality?
It should also investigate:
Does educational inequality contribute to fertility differences?
A longitudinal approach would be particularly useful.
Weakness 4: Insufficient emphasis on educational expenditure
Family size is not equivalent to educational investment.
Two households with the same number of children may spend very different amounts
on education.
For example:
|
Household |
Monthly household income |
Number of children |
Monthly education expenditure
per child |
|
A |
₹20,000 |
2 |
₹1,500 |
|
B |
₹60,000 |
4 |
₹3,000 |
|
C |
₹25,000 |
3 |
₹800 |
|
D |
₹1,00,000 |
3 |
₹6,000 |
Illustrative hypothetical figures, not observed survey data.
The comparison demonstrates why family size must be studied alongside income
and educational expenditure.
Weakness 5: Gender-specific educational disadvantages
Educational inequality may occur within households.
Where resources are limited, girls may face disadvantages in continuation to
secondary or higher education because of household responsibilities, safety
concerns, transport limitations or social expectations.
A family-size model without sufficiently detailed gender analysis may fail
to identify these differences.
Weakness 6: Differences within religious groups
Hindu and Muslim populations are not economically or socially homogeneous.
There are substantial differences in income, geography, rural and urban
residence, parental education, occupation and access to institutions within
each population.
Therefore, religious categories should not be treated as independent
explanations of educational behaviour.
The research should distinguish religious identity from the socioeconomic
conditions correlated with it.
Weakness 7: Educational attainment requires multiple indicators
Years of schooling alone cannot fully explain educational inequality.
A more comprehensive framework should consider:
·
Primary school completion.
·
Upper-primary transition.
·
Secondary school completion.
·
Higher secondary completion.
·
College enrolment.
·
Higher education graduation.
·
Learning outcomes and educational quality.
A child may complete several years of schooling without acquiring the
expected learning outcomes.
5.4 Overall critical assessment
|
Assessment criterion |
Evaluation |
Critical observation |
|
Originality |
Strong |
Relevant application of fertility economics to Indian education |
|
Significance |
Strong |
Important demographic and educational policy question |
|
Interest |
Strong |
Connects family economics with social inequality |
|
Clarity |
Good |
Central argument is identifiable |
|
Relevance |
Strong |
Relevant to Indian development policy |
|
Correctness |
Requires qualification |
Decomposition contributions should not automatically be interpreted
causally |
|
Methodology |
Promising |
Requires scrutiny of identification and robustness in the complete paper |
|
Presentation |
Good |
Quantitative findings offer a clear basis for discussion |
|
Policy implications |
Good |
Could be expanded towards institutional and household-level interventions |
These are the present reviewer's assessments, not the original journal's
evaluation scores.
6. Methodology of the Critical
Research
6.1 Research design
The present study adopts a critical review and secondary-data analytical
approach.
It does not attempt to reproduce the original authors' econometric estimates
because the complete underlying microdata and estimation specifications have
not been independently reprocessed for this review.
Instead, it examines:
1. The
theoretical assumptions of the original article.
2. The
decomposition findings reported by the authors.
3. Official
fertility statistics.
4. Changes
in demographic indicators between NFHS-4 and NFHS-5.
5. The
implications of those changes for educational policy.
6.2 Data sources
|
Data source |
Period |
Purpose |
|
Sen, Surana and Basant |
2023 |
Main research article |
|
NFHS-4 |
2015–16 |
Earlier fertility comparison |
|
NFHS-5 |
2019–21 |
Updated fertility comparison |
|
Becker and Lewis |
1973 |
Theoretical framework |
|
Black et al. |
2005 |
Family-size and educational outcomes literature |
|
Rosenzweig and Zhang |
2009 |
Endogeneity and human capital research |
|
Diebolt et al. |
2021 |
Education, fertility and gender empowerment |
6.3 Analytical techniques
The review employs the following methods:
A. Descriptive analysis
Comparison of fertility rates across demographic groups.
B. Percentage difference analysis
Calculation of the relative fertility gap between Hindu and Muslim women.
Formula:
\[ \text{Relative Fertility Gap} =
\frac{TFR_M-TFR_H}{TFR_H}\times100 \]
Where:
·
\(TFR_M\) = Muslim total fertility rate.
·
\(TFR_H\) = Hindu total fertility rate.
C. Trend analysis
Comparison of NFHS-4 and NFHS-5 fertility indicators.
D. Critical decomposition assessment
Evaluation of the distinction between the explained contribution of family
size and the total educational gap.
E. Policy analysis
Assessment of the implications for educational expenditure, school
accessibility, gender equality and household economic conditions.
6.4 Ethical considerations
The study uses published research and publicly available demographic
statistics.
It does not collect personal information or conduct interviews.
Religious identity is treated as a demographic classification for
statistical examination, not as a measure of individual ability, preference or
educational potential.
The analysis avoids attributing educational disadvantage to religious
identity without considering economic and institutional circumstances.
7. Results and Discussion
7.1 Fertility differences: NFHS-4
and NFHS-5
One of the most important ways to critically examine the original research
is to investigate whether the demographic conditions identified in the 2015–16
period continued in subsequent years.
The following figures are taken from the official NFHS reports. [7], [8].
Table 1. Total fertility rate by religion
Average number of children per woman
|
Religious group |
NFHS-4 (2015–16) |
NFHS-5 (2019–21) |
Absolute decline |
|
Hindu |
2.13 |
1.94 |
0.19 |
|
Muslim |
2.62 |
2.36 |
0.26 |
|
Christian |
1.99 |
1.88 |
0.11 |
|
Sikh |
1.58 |
1.61 |
-0.03 |
|
Buddhist/Neo-Buddhist |
1.74 |
1.39 |
0.35 |
|
Jain |
1.20 |
1.60 |
-0.40 |
|
India total |
2.18 |
1.99 |
0.19 |
Source: NFHS-4 and NFHS-5, Table 4.2. Negative decline indicates an
increase. [7], [8].
Interpretation
Three important observations emerge.
First: Muslim fertility declined from 2.62 to 2.36 children
per woman.
Second: Hindu fertility declined from 2.13 to 1.94 children
per woman.
Third: Both groups experienced declining fertility,
although the decline was greater in absolute terms among Muslim women.
The data demonstrate that fertility differences are dynamic rather than
permanent demographic characteristics.
Figure 1. Comparison of Hindu and
Muslim fertility rates
Total fertility rate by religion
Critical interpretation: The decline in fertility does not
automatically establish that educational inequality has declined at the same
rate. Educational outcomes are influenced by several other factors, including
historical differences in educational access, household resources and school
quality.
7.2 Analysis of the changing
fertility gap
The relative difference between Muslim and Hindu fertility can be calculated
for both survey periods.
Table 2. Relative fertility gap
|
Indicator |
NFHS-4 |
NFHS-5 |
|
Muslim TFR |
2.62 |
2.36 |
|
Hindu TFR |
2.13 |
1.94 |
|
Absolute difference |
0.49 |
0.42 |
|
Relative difference |
23.00% |
21.65% |
Calculations:
NFHS-4:
\[ \frac{2.62-2.13}{2.13}\times100 =23.00\% \]
NFHS-5:
\[ \frac{2.36-1.94}{1.94}\times100 =21.65\% \]
Author's calculations using published NFHS figures. The original article
refers to a historical difference of approximately 24%; small differences can
arise from rounding and the underlying calculation.
Figure 2. Declining relative
fertility difference
Relative Muslim–Hindu fertility difference
.png)
Discussion
The relative fertility difference decreased by approximately 1.35 percentage
points.
This is an important demographic development.
However, the decrease should not be interpreted as evidence that the
educational gap has reduced by 1.35 percentage points.
The two indicators measure different outcomes.
A proper assessment would require comparing educational attainment across
the same religious groups, survey periods, age cohorts and socioeconomic
categories.
This is an important opportunity for further research.
7.3 Fertility and women's education
NFHS-5 also provides evidence that fertility varies considerably with
women's educational attainment.
Table 3. Fertility by women's
schooling, India, 2019–21
|
Educational attainment |
Total fertility rate |
|
No schooling |
2.82 |
|
Less than 5 years |
2.30 |
|
5–7 years |
2.21 |
|
8–9 years |
2.12 |
|
10–11 years |
1.88 |
|
12 or more years |
1.78 |
Source: NFHS-5, Table 4.2. [8].
Figure 3. Relationship between
women's education and fertility
Women's education and total fertility rate

Interpretation
The difference between women without schooling and those with 12 or more
years of education is 1.04 children per woman.
This finding provides an important insight.
Education is not merely an outcome influenced by demographic conditions. It
is also associated with fertility behaviour.
The relationship therefore operates in both directions.
Critical observation: Policies that improve women's
educational attainment may influence fertility outcomes while simultaneously
strengthening women's employment opportunities, economic independence and
decision-making capacity.
However, the table is descriptive and does not establish the independent
causal effect of education on fertility.
7.4 Fertility and household wealth
Another important dimension is the relationship between household wealth and
fertility.
Table 4. Fertility by household
wealth, NFHS-5
|
Wealth category |
Total fertility rate |
|
Lowest |
2.63 |
|
Second |
2.12 |
|
Middle |
1.89 |
|
Fourth |
1.74 |
|
Highest |
1.57 |
Source: NFHS-5, Table 4.2. [8].
Figure 4. Household wealth and
fertility

Interpretation
The difference between the lowest and highest wealth categories is 1.06
children per woman.
This demonstrates the importance of socioeconomic circumstances in
understanding fertility patterns.
It also raises an important methodological question for the original
research:
To what extent does the family-size contribution remain when differences in
household wealth, parental education and residential location are carefully
considered?
This should be investigated through additional specifications and
sensitivity analysis.
7.5 The 10% and 16% findings: A
deeper critical examination
The original article reports that family size accounts for approximately 10%
of the years-of-schooling gap and approximately 16% of the secondary education
completion gap.
These results deserve careful interpretation.
Table 5. Critical interpretation of
the original decomposition
|
Outcome |
Family-size contribution |
Remaining gap outside
family-size component |
|
Years of schooling |
10% |
90% |
|
Secondary completion |
16% |
84% |
The remaining percentages are calculated arithmetically. They are not
estimates of any individual omitted factor.
Figure 5. Family size versus the
remaining measured gap

Contribution of family size to the reported
education gap
Original article's approximate decomposition findings.
Critical interpretation
The results demonstrate that the contribution of family size differs
according to the educational outcome.
Its contribution is higher for secondary education completion than for years
of schooling.
One possible explanation is that secondary education requires sustained
financial expenditure, transport, academic support and a longer period of
household investment.
However, this explanation is a hypothesis requiring further testing.
The original estimates do not establish which other factors explain the
remaining gap.
A future study should separately examine:
1. Household
income and consumption.
2. Parental
education.
3. Gender
differences.
4. School
availability.
5. Distance
to secondary schools.
6. Educational
expenditure per child.
7. Rural
and urban differences.
8. Employment
and child-care responsibilities.
7.6 The hidden economic dimensions
of educational inequality
The original research provides an important starting point, but a broader
economic interpretation requires examining the household as an economic
decision-making unit.
The following conceptual framework extends the original argument.
This framework suggests that family size should be examined as one explanatory variable within a larger economic system.
.7 Comparison with existing research
Table 6. Comparative theoretical and
empirical assessment
|
Research |
Main focus |
Contribution to the present
critique |
|
Becker and Lewis (1973) |
Quantity–quality trade-off |
Establishes the theoretical mechanism |
|
Black et al. (2005) |
Family size and educational outcomes |
Emphasises the need for identification |
|
Rosenzweig and Zhang (2009) |
Family size and human capital |
Highlights causal inference |
|
Sen et al. (2023) |
Fertility and educational gap in India |
Provides the main decomposition findings |
|
Diebolt et al. (2021) |
Education and fertility |
Highlights gender empowerment and reverse causality |
The comparative assessment indicates that fertility, education and economic
development are interconnected.
The strongest interpretation is not that family size independently
determines educational attainment, but that household decisions interact with
financial and institutional opportunities.
8. Extended Discussion: What Does
the Research Actually Establish?
A critical research paper must distinguish between what the original study
establishes, what its findings suggest and what remains untested.
Table 7. Evidence versus
interpretation
|
Research issue |
What the evidence establishes |
What remains to be investigated |
|
Fertility differences |
Fertility differs across religious groups |
Independent causes of these differences |
|
Family size and education |
Family size contributes to the measured education gap |
Causal impact of an additional child |
|
Secondary education |
Reported family-size contribution is higher |
Role of transport, safety and school costs |
|
Women's education |
Higher schooling is associated with lower fertility |
Direction and magnitude of causal effects |
|
Household wealth |
Fertility varies by wealth category |
Interaction between wealth and religious differences |
|
Educational inequality |
Family size explains only part of the gap |
Specific contribution of other economic and institutional factors |
8.1 Why secondary education deserves
greater attention
Primary education and secondary education have different economic
characteristics.
Primary schooling may be available within a village or neighbourhood, while
secondary schooling may require additional transportation and greater household
expenditure.
For families with limited financial resources, the transition to secondary
education can create a significant economic burden.
The following variables should therefore be incorporated into future
research:
·
Distance from residence to secondary school.
·
Availability of public transport.
·
School fees and examination expenses.
·
Digital learning access.
·
Availability of scholarships.
·
Gender-specific safety concerns.
·
Household expenditure on private tuition.
8.2 Why fertility-based policy is
insufficient
The findings should not be translated into policies that treat higher
fertility as a deficiency or attribute educational outcomes to religious
identity.
A more effective policy approach is to ensure that children receive
educational opportunities regardless of their family size.
The economic objective should be to increase the quality and accessibility
of educational investment.
This is especially important in a country where fertility has already
declined substantially and educational inequality continues to require
attention.
9. Recommendations for Further
Empirical Research
The present review proposes a more comprehensive empirical model to
investigate educational inequality.
9.1 Proposed multidimensional model
The dependent variable should be educational attainment, measured separately
through:
·
Years of completed schooling.
·
Secondary school completion.
·
Higher secondary completion.
·
Higher education enrolment.
·
Higher education completion.
The independent variables should include:
|
Variable |
Measurement |
Expected relationship with
education |
|
Family size |
Number of children |
Potentially negative |
|
Household income |
Monthly/annual income |
Positive |
|
Mother's education |
Years of schooling |
Positive |
|
Father's education |
Years of schooling |
Positive |
|
Gender |
Male/female |
Context-dependent |
|
Rural residence |
Rural/urban |
Depends on institutional access |
|
School distance |
Kilometres |
Potentially negative |
|
Education expenditure |
Expenditure per child |
Positive |
|
Parental occupation |
Employment category |
Context-dependent |
|
Scholarship access |
Beneficiary/non-beneficiary |
Potentially positive |
9.2 Proposed Econometric Framework
Future empirical research should adopt a multidimensional econometric
framework to examine the combined influence of fertility, household economic
conditions and institutional factors on educational attainment. Educational
attainment may be considered the dependent variable, measured through years of
completed schooling, secondary school completion, higher secondary education
and higher education enrolment. The independent variables should include family
size, household income, mother's education, father's education, gender, rural
or urban residence, school accessibility, educational expenditure per child and
scholarship availability. A multiple regression model may be employed to
examine the relationship between these variables and educational attainment,
expressed as:
Educational Attainment = β₀ + β₁(Family Size) + β₂(Household Income) +
β₃(Mother's Education) + β₄(Gender) + β₅(School Accessibility) + Error Term
Where:
·
β₀ = Constant term
·
β₁ = Coefficient of family size
·
β₂ = Coefficient of household income
·
β₃ = Coefficient of mother's education
·
β₄ = Coefficient of gender
·
β₅ = Coefficient of school accessibility
·
Error Term = Unexplained variation in
educational attainment.
This regression model examines how demographic, economic and institutional
factors jointly influence educational attainment.
For binary educational outcomes, such as completion or non-completion of
secondary education, logistic regression may be applied. Furthermore,
Oaxaca–Blinder decomposition can be used to examine differences in continuous
educational outcomes, while Fairlie decomposition may be appropriate for binary
outcomes. To strengthen causal interpretation, future researchers should
consider instrumental variable techniques, longitudinal household data, sibling
and birth-order comparisons, and natural experiments wherever suitable data and
valid identification assumptions are available. Robustness checks and
sensitivity analysis should also be conducted to assess the stability of the
results. Such an integrated econometric framework would help determine whether
educational inequality is primarily associated with fertility differences or
whether household income, parental education, gender disparities and
institutional accessibility play equally or more significant roles.
9.3 Suggested future research title
Beyond Family Size: Household Economics, Gender and Institutional
Determinants of Educational Inequality in India.
This would extend the original research by examining the economic and
institutional mechanisms that operate alongside fertility.
10. Policy Recommendations
The critical analysis suggests that educational policy should focus on
improving opportunities for children rather than concentrating exclusively on
demographic differences.
10.1 Recommendations to the Ministry
of Education
1. Strengthen
secondary education infrastructure in economically disadvantaged areas.
2. Improve
access to government schools and quality teaching.
3. Introduce
targeted educational assistance based on household economic disadvantage.
4. Improve
transition rates from primary to secondary education.
5. Expand
digital educational infrastructure in rural areas.
10.2 Recommendations for women's
education
1. Improve
girls' continuation into secondary and higher secondary education.
2. Expand
scholarships for economically disadvantaged girls.
3. Improve
safe transportation to schools and colleges.
4. Increase
access to vocational and professional education.
5. Strengthen
adult education and parental literacy programmes.
10.3 Recommendations for family and
social policy
1. Improve
access to voluntary family planning services.
2. Increase
awareness of reproductive health.
3. Ensure
access to maternal and child healthcare.
4. Integrate
educational awareness with community development programmes.
5. Avoid
treating religious identity as a substitute for socioeconomic assessment.
10.4 Recommendations for researchers
1. Use
updated NFHS datasets.
2. Examine
household-level educational expenditure.
3. Analyse
gender differences in school continuation.
4. Distinguish
between correlation and causation.
5. Examine
educational outcomes within religious and socioeconomic groups.
6. Compare
regional differences across Indian states.
7. Conduct
longitudinal research wherever possible.
11. Conclusion
The research by Sen, Surana and Basant (2023) makes a valuable contribution
to the understanding of educational inequality in India by investigating the
relationship between fertility and educational attainment.
Its application of quantity–quality theory provides an important economic
explanation for why larger families may face difficulties in allocating
sufficient educational resources to each child.
However, the present critical review establishes that fertility is only one
component of a much broader educational and socioeconomic framework.
The original research reports that family size explains approximately 10% of
the years-of-schooling gap between Muslims and high-caste Hindus and
approximately 16% of the secondary education completion gap.
These findings are important, but they also demonstrate the limitations of
fertility-centred explanations.
The subsequent NFHS-5 data show a decline in fertility among both Hindu and
Muslim women. Muslim fertility declined from 2.62 to 2.36, while Hindu
fertility declined from 2.13 to 1.94 between NFHS-4 and NFHS-5.
This demographic transition strengthens the argument that educational
inequality should be investigated through a wider economic and institutional
perspective.
The relationship between fertility and education is not unidirectional.
Women's education can influence fertility decisions, while family size can
influence household educational investment. Both are also affected by income,
employment, gender relations, public infrastructure and social opportunities.
The most important conclusion of this review is that reducing
educational inequality requires improving the educational opportunities
available to every child, irrespective of household size, economic background
or religious identity.
India's educational development strategy should therefore move beyond
demographic explanations towards a comprehensive framework incorporating
household economics, gender empowerment, institutional accessibility,
educational quality and human capital development.
11.1 Theoretical implications
The review extends the application of quantity–quality theory by placing
fertility within a wider household resource allocation framework.
11.2 Practical implications
Educational institutions and policymakers should prioritise affordable
secondary education, scholarships, transport, parental awareness and equal
opportunities.
11.3 Limitations of the present
review
1. The
original study's underlying microdata were not independently re-estimated.
2. The
full original article's detailed regression tables, standard errors, sample
construction and robustness specifications could not be independently verified
from the accessible publication record and abstract.
3. NFHS-4
and NFHS-5 are separate survey rounds and do not constitute a longitudinal
panel following the same households.
4. The
descriptive fertility comparisons do not independently establish causal
relationships.
5. The
present review does not independently calculate the religious
educational-attainment gap for NFHS-5.
Accordingly, the present findings should be treated as a critical
secondary-data review rather than a replication of the original econometric
research.
11.4 Future research directions
Future studies should investigate the combined influence of fertility,
household income, women's education, educational expenditure and institutional
accessibility using updated household-level data.
Particular attention should be given to secondary education and the
transition to higher education, where economic and institutional barriers may
become more pronounced.
12. References
IEEE citation style
[1] G. Sen, M. Surana, and R. Basant, "To What Extent Does the
Fertility Rate Explain the Education Gap?," Population Research and
Policy Review, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 1–31, Jun. 2023. doi: 10.1007/s11113-023-09783-1.
[2] G. Sen, M. Surana, and R. Basant, "To What Extent Does the
Fertility Rate Explain the Education Gap?," ResearchGate, Apr. 2023.
[Online]. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/370292576_To_What_Extent_Does_the_Fertility_Rate_Explain_the_Education_Gap
[3] G. S. Becker and H. G. Lewis, "On the Interaction between the
Quantity and Quality of Children," Journal of Political Economy,
vol. 81, no. 2, Part 2, pp. S279–S288, Mar. 1973. doi: 10.1086/260166.
[4] S. E. Black, P. J. Devereux, and K. G. Salvanes, "The More the
Merrier? The Effect of Family Size and Birth Order on Children's
Education," The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 120, no. 2,
pp. 669–700, May 2005.
[5] M. R. Rosenzweig and J. Zhang, "Do Population Control Policies
Induce More Human Capital Investment? Twins, Birth Weight and China's
'One-Child' Policy," The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 76, no.
3, pp. 1149–1174, Jul. 2009.
[6] C. Diebolt, T. Mishra, and F. Perrin, "Gender Empowerment as an
Enforcer of Individuals' Choice between Education and Fertility: Evidence from
19th Century France," Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,
vol. 188, pp. 408–438, Aug. 2021. doi: 10.1016/j.jebo.2021.05.011.
[7] International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) and ICF, National
Family Health Survey (NFHS-4), 2015–16: India. Mumbai, India: IIPS, 2017.
[8] International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) and ICF, National
Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), 2019–21: India. Mumbai, India: IIPS, 2021.
[9] R. W. Fairlie, "An Extension of the Blinder-Oaxaca Decomposition
Technique to Logit and Probit Models," Journal of Economic and Social
Measurement, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 305–316, 2005. doi:
10.3233/JEM-2005-0259.
[10] Y. Tong, "Sidebar: Demographic Profiles of India's Major Religious
Groups," Pew Research Center, Aug. 23, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2022/08/23/sidebar-demographic-profiles/

