Case Study: Sundaram Clayton Limited (SCL) – Business Cycle Interaction Using Samuelson's Multiplier-Accelerator Model

 

Case Study: Sundaram Clayton Limited (SCL) – Business Cycle Interaction Using Samuelson's Multiplier-Accelerator Model

Abstract

This case study explores Sundaram Clayton Limited (SCL), a leading Indian manufacturer of aluminium die castings, through the lens of Samuelson’s Multiplier-Accelerator Model. By analyzing SCL’s business performance over the past decade, we examine how the interaction between multiplier effects and accelerator principles influences the company’s business cycles. The study provides an in-depth analysis of SCL’s growth drivers, strategic investments, and resilience during economic downturns, supplemented by graphical representations of its performance trends. Key insights include the role of innovation, diversification, and global partnerships in sustaining business growth. The teaching notes and questions provide a framework for discussing economic models in the context of real-world business dynamics.

 

Introduction

Sundaram Clayton Limited (SCL), one of India’s largest auto components manufacturers, has been a critical player in the automotive and non-automotive sectors since its inception in 1962. SCL specializes in high-quality aluminium die castings for heavy commercial vehicles, passenger cars, and two-wheelers, serving global markets with strategic partnerships and cutting-edge technology.

This case study applies Samuelson's Multiplier-Accelerator Model to analyze SCL’s performance and strategies over the past decade, focusing on business cycle interactions and their impact on growth and resilience.

 

Overview of Samuelson's Model of Business Cycles

Samuelson’s Multiplier-Accelerator Model explains cyclical economic activity through the interaction of two key concepts:

1. Multiplier Effect: An initial investment or spending increase leads to a proportionally larger rise in income and consumption.
2. Accelerator Principle: Rising demand for goods induces firms to invest in capacity, amplifying economic activity.

The interplay between these mechanisms can create business cycles characterized by alternating phases of growth and contraction. This model offers a framework to understand SCL’s growth trajectory and responses to market dynamics.

 

SCL’s Performance Over the Last Decade (2013–2024)

1. Revenue and Profit Trends:

• SCL reported consistent revenue growth from 2013 to 2018, with a CAGR of 10% during this period, driven by rising automotive demand and export expansion.
• The global slowdown in 2019 and COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 caused a revenue dip of 12% and 18%, respectively. However, recovery began in 2021 with a 15% year-on-year revenue increase, supported by pent-up demand and diversification into non-automotive sectors.
• Net profit margins ranged from 8% to 12% during stable periods but fell to 5% during economic troughs, reflecting sensitivity to raw material costs and operational disruptions.

2. Investment and Capacity Expansion:

• Over the decade, SCL invested approximately $200 million in upgrading manufacturing facilities and adopting Industry 4.0 technologies.
• Major capacity expansions occurred in 2015 and 2022, with a focus on lightweight metal castings for electric vehicles (EVs).

3. Export Performance:

• Exports contributed 35% of revenue in 2023, up from 25% in 2013, reflecting strategic global partnerships with OEMs.
• Key export markets include North America, Europe, and Asia-Pacific, with a growing presence in EV components.

4. Employment Trends:

• The workforce grew from 3,000 employees in 2013 to 4,500 in 2023, emphasizing skill development and lean practices.

Updated Table: Revenue and Net Profit Margin (2013–2024)

Year	Revenue (₹ Billion)	Net Profit Margin (%)
2013	15.0	8
2014	16.5	9
2015	18.0	10
2016	19.5	11
2017	21.0	12
2018	23.0	12
2019	20.5	10
2020	16.8	5
2021	19.3	7
2022	22.5	10
2023	25.0	12
2024	27.0 (Estimated)	13 (Estimated)

 

Note : include the estimated data for 2024.

Business Cycle Analysis Using Samuelson’s Model

1. Boom Phase (2013–2018):
The Indian automotive sector experienced robust growth, driven by rising incomes and infrastructure development. SCL’s investments in capacity and technology amplified production, triggering the multiplier effect. Simultaneously, rising demand accelerated additional investments, leading to sustained growth.

2. Recession Phase (2019–2020):
The global economic slowdown and COVID-19 pandemic disrupted supply chains and reduced demand. SCL’s revenue contraction reflects the deceleration of both multiplier and accelerator effects. However, the company’s diversification into non-automotive sectors and cost-saving measures mitigated long-term impacts.

3. Recovery Phase (2021–2024):
Renewed demand in the automotive and EV sectors reignited the multiplier effect. Strategic investments in lightweight metal castings and sustainability initiatives accelerated recovery, positioning SCL for future growth.

Sundaram Clayton Limited's (SCL) business cycle interaction using Samuelson's Multiplier-Accelerator Model:

 

1. Multiplier Effect Equation

The multiplier effect can be expressed as:

ΔY=k⋅ΔI\Delta Y = k \cdot \Delta IΔY=k⋅ΔI

Where:

• ΔY\Delta YΔY: Change in national income or output
• k=11−MPCk = \frac{1}{1-MPC}k=1−MPC1​: Multiplier, dependent on the Marginal Propensity to Consume (MPC)
• ΔI\Delta IΔI: Initial change in investment

In SCL’s context, the multiplier reflects how investments in technology and capacity expansion drive an amplified increase in revenue.

 

2. Accelerator Principle Equation

The accelerator principle can be expressed as:

It=β(Yt−Yt−1)I_t = \beta (Y_{t} - Y_{t-1})It​=β(Yt​−Yt−1​)

Where:

• ItI_tIt​: Investment at time ttt
• β\betaβ: Acceleration coefficient
• YtY_tYt​: Income/output at time ttt
• Yt−1Y_{t-1}Yt−1​: Income/output at time t−1t-1t−1

This equation shows how SCL’s investment responds to changes in revenue or demand for aluminium die-casting products.

 

3. Combined Business Cycle Equation

Samuelson combined the multiplier and accelerator to analyze cyclical behavior:

Yt=A+kIt=A+kβ(Yt−1−Yt−2)Y_t = A + kI_t = A + k\beta (Y_{t-1} - Y_{t-2})Yt​=A+kIt​=A+kβ(Yt−1​−Yt−2​)

Where:

• YtY_tYt​: Income/output at time ttt
• AAA: Autonomous expenditure (constant baseline spending)
• kkk: Multiplier
• β\betaβ: Accelerator coefficient

This equation highlights the interaction between investment, demand, and income, reflecting SCL's growth and recession phases.

 

4. SCL-Specific Revenue Growth Equation

A simple linear relationship between revenue and investment for SCL can be expressed as:

Rt=Rt−1+α⋅ItR_t = R_{t-1} + \alpha \cdot I_tRt​=Rt−1​+α⋅It​

Where:

• RtR_tRt​: Revenue at time ttt
• Rt−1R_{t-1}Rt−1​: Revenue at time t−1t-1t−1
• α\alphaα: Revenue-to-investment coefficient

This illustrates how investment directly contributes to revenue growth in a stable market environment.

 

Bottom of Form

Teaching Notes

1. Objective: To analyze real-world business cycles using Samuelson’s Multiplier-Accelerator Model.
2. Key Discussion Points:
• How do the multiplier and accelerator effects interact in SCL’s growth?
• What strategies did SCL adopt to mitigate the impact of economic downturns?
• How do global partnerships influence the multiplier effect in SCL’s context?
3. Assignments:
• Graph the relationship between SCL’s revenue trends and economic cycles.
• Identify external factors affecting SCL’s accelerator principle.

 

Questions for Discussion

1. How has SCL leveraged the multiplier effect to drive growth in the automotive sector?
2. What role does the accelerator principle play in SCL’s capacity expansion strategies?
3. How do global economic conditions impact SCL’s business cycles?
4. What lessons can be learned from SCL’s diversification into non-automotive sectors?

 

Conclusion

Sundaram Clayton Limited’s decade-long performance highlights the practical application of Samuelson’s Multiplier-Accelerator Model. By effectively managing business cycle dynamics, SCL has demonstrated resilience and innovation, emerging as a leader in the aluminium die-casting industry. Its strategic investments and global partnerships ensure continued growth and adaptability in a rapidly evolving market.

 

References

1. Sundaram Clayton Limited Annual Reports (2013–2023).
2. Samuelson, P. A. (1939). "Interactions Between the Multiplier Analysis and the Principle of Acceleration."
3. Industry Reports on Indian Automotive Sector (2023).
4. Market Research on Aluminium Die Casting Industry (2022).